New immigration bill troubling

Inaccurate weather reports
12:56 p.m.
‘Over-reliance  on test scores  is not good’
12:55 p.m.
A pleasure to live  in Madison Twp.
12:52 p.m.
The cost per vote?
7:12 a.m.
‘Eliminate all the frivolous noise’
2/8/10
> More opinion headlines

Updated 7:45 PM Monday, May 18, 2009

Ohio apparently will become the next state to consider legislation to require employers to verify the citizenship of prospective employees. Similar efforts have been established or are proposed in Oklahoma, Colorado, Georgia, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, Rhode Island, Arizona, Mississippi, South Carolina and Utah, according to the National Immigration Law Center.

Ohio’s version of the law — dubbed the “Ohio Job Integrity Preservation Act” — was to be introduced this week by state Rep. Courtney Combs, R-Hamilton, and was announced last week in a press conference that included Combs and Butler County Sheriff Richard K. Jones. The bill is the latest volley in the high-profile campaign waged by Jones — and Combs, to a lesser extent — against illegal immigration.

To its credit, this bill finally recognizes the connection between any influx of illegal immigrants and the willingness of American businesses to hire them under the table as cheap laborers. The main targets of Combs’ bill are employers, and Jones — who says the measure will be “controversial” — promises that “fines will be pretty enormous. ... Maybe millions, maybe losing their businesses or going to jail.”

And maybe that’s why the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other parties have challenged the law in Oklahoma where, earlier this month, a federal appeals court heard arguments from both sides. (Another court has upheld Arizona’s law despite challenges.)

Tellingly, local chamber of commerce officials have not yet endorsed the measure. Bill Triick, president of the Middletown area’s chamber, said questions about costs and time allowances for employers must be answered before the local business community can support the measure. A Combs spokesman said the federal “E-Verify” database used only requires an Internet connection and its tutorial takes an hour.

We, too, have concerns about the bill, but we’re pleased to see Jones’ stance on the immigration issue evolve and mature. Instead of persecuting the people who have been lured across borders by the promise of jobs, Jones and Combs are now taking dead aim at the businesses that hire undocumented workers.

Of course, this may be a problem that is being corrected by market forces. A report last week indicated that scattered anti-immigrant laws and the deepening economic recession have unexpectedly slowed the growth of the Hispanic and Asian populations in America. And with the national unemployment rate approaching double digits, it’s no longer true that Americans won’t take the jobs that, many said, only immigrants would work, Combs says.

Here are a few questions and concerns we have about the bill:

• It requires employers to use E-Verify, which allows them to check Social Security and Homeland Security records “to ensure that a potential employee is legally able to work in the United States,” according to Combs’ office. Congress created E-Verify as part of an immigration bill in 1996, and most states still don’t require employers to use it, according to the Associated Press. The U.S. Chamber and other strange-bedfellows critics, such as the American Civil Liberties Union and labor unions, say the E-Verify system is unreliable and that Congress did not make it mandatory because it’s flawed. Questions about its reliability and other states’ experiences should be answered before Ohio considers mandating its use.

• What’s the hurry? With immigrant population growth slowing, why not allow the pending court cases to be resolved first? Why invite an expensive court battle here? Because similar bills in other states are controversial and have been challenged, the bill offered by Combs — and backed by Jones — appears to be a strong political statement, rather than thoughtful legislation.

• We’re also concerned about the bill’s provision that requires local jail officials in Ohio to make “reasonable efforts toward verifying the citizenship of all persons charged and confined within a jail,” and then notifying Homeland Security if citizenship can’t be established. Besides the obvious expense to local governments, this provision mandates that all local police agencies take the same aggressive — and controversial — anti-immigrant stances that Jones has adopted here. Columbus has no business telling local police departments how to run their jails or to do the federal government’s job.

The most serious concern we have about this bill is the unintended discrimination it could cause in workplaces across Ohio. If this bill becomes law, employers may find it much easier to simply skip over any job applicants whose names are of Hispanic or Asian origin — whether those applicants are here legally or not — rather than invite unwanted attention and possible fines. For that reason alone, the “Ohio Job Integrity Preservation Act” deserves critical scrutiny before state lawmakers give it serious consideration.

Share this article

ADD COMMENT

Comments feed

It is long over due! If this is applied to the rest of the fifty states it will work to together and save millions of $ in taxpayers money in the long run.

legal immigrant
12:38 AM, 10/23/2009

REPORT ABUSE

Ever heard of the grass roots level? If every city and county nationwide did their part to eliminate the illegals, then the problem would be solved nationally. I have no problem making the Federal government look bad. If you've got a SS card, show it to potential employers. That makes it difficult for SS to deny citizenship. It's a good thing I don't work in a hospital. There would be a lot of illegal, immigrant babies born on the waiting room floor!

blou
4:29 PM, 5/29/2009

REPORT ABUSE

Taxpayer, you really sound like you're benefiting in some way. To your comments, I’m not religious and I have more insight into business, etc. than I’ll share. In regard to schools, they have to add teachers at a certain number of kids per class too. In regard to other costs, including births, it's not too difficult to find. Which again makes me wonder about your motivation, let alone that you’re words are far more God like than mine. And, I trust more taxpayers agree with this plan.

Anonymous
1:21 PM, 5/29/2009

REPORT ABUSE

Politicians, read the newspaper to find out how much money you don't have. Quit wasting our money especially with problems that sound great to solve, but you know that you can't begin to scratch the surface of this enormous problem. The federal government has to do this. Don't waste our money to increase your political standing. Gullable people don't realize how much money you are wasting.

taxpayer money
12:25 PM, 5/29/2009

REPORT ABUSE

You must be retired and out of touch with reality.
The jobs are probably not on record and if they are using ss numbers that receive payments and taxes are taken out. You can't make up costs you don't know anything about like birthing? How starange? Are you Christian? You act like God. Schools have programs for many legals with help for English. The problem is huge. Don't play games and waste our money.

taxpayer money
10:11 PM, 5/28/2009

REPORT ABUSE

There are 28 additional comments

SHOW ALL

We welcome your comments. Please remember this is a public forum and behave appropriately. Your comments must conform to our visitor's agreement.