Latest featured videos from MiddletownJournal.com
October 2008 | Butler County News and Issues
 

Home > Blogs > Butler County News and Issues > Archives > 2008 > October

October 2008

Elections Commission to investigate judge campaign

A complaint filed in the Ohio Elections Commission Wednesday, Oct. 28, alleges that Judge Glenda Smith, who is running against attorney Dan Haughey to keep her job on Butler County Area III Court, has violated state election law.

The complaint (below) says that Smith’s yard signs, mailers and other campaign materials use a P.O. box instead of address, which is in violation of state election rules.

Here’s the filing (Click on the top right corner to enlarge). It includes examples of her mailers and Web site, as well as a copy of an earlier advisory opinion:

Smith is a Democrat who was appointed as judge by the governor in September to replace Robert Hendrickson, who resigned to run for higher court. Local Republicans say her inability to follow the letter of the law shows she isn’t qualified to be a judge.

The Elections Commission hasn’t ruled on the issue, and has scheduled a preliminary hearing on Nov. 20.

Permalink | Comments (3) | Post your comment | Categories: Crime and courts

Boehner: Obama votes like a chicken

U.S. House Minority Leader John Boehner, R-West Chester Twp., has been stumping for Sen. John McCain for a few days now. And he is not mincing words, according to this report of a speech he gave in Oxford Wednesday.

Said Boeher:

“Now, listen, I’ve voted ‘present’ two or three times in my entire 25-year political career, where there might have been a conflict of interest and I didn’t feel like I should vote…In Congress, we have a red button, a green button and a yellow button, alright. Green means ‘yes,’ red means ‘no,’ and yellow means you’re a chicken (expletive). And the last thing we need in the White House, in the oval office, behind that big desk, is some chicken who wants to push this yellow button.”

The expletive is a synonym for feces.

How do you feel about Boehner’s comments?

Permalink | Comments (6) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Ohio Chamber releases endorsements

The below press release is from the Ohio of Commerce. The business community supports the Republican slate. This is about as big a surprise as learning that local college students support Sen. Barack Obama.

OUR PRO-BUSINESS STATE SENATE AND REPRESENTATIVE CANDIDATES

Your business needs government leaders at the state level who are on your side! The Ohio Chamber of Commerce recently released their list of officially endorsed candidates for 2008 for the Ohio House of Representatives and State Senate. The Ohio Chamber makes these endorsement decisions based on the pro-business voting record of each current office holder. In the case of candidates who haven’t held public office, the Ohio Chamber makes endorsements based on candidate questionnaires and interviews. Butler County has 4 candidates for the next Ohio General Assembly who have received the Ohio Chamber of Commerce endorsement for 2008. These candidates will be on the ballot on November 4th.

OUR AREA STATE CANDIDATES THAT HAVE BEEN ENDORSED BY THE OHIO CHAMBER OF COMMERCE INCLUDE:

  • For State Senate, Senator Gary Cates, 4th District
  • For State Representative, Rep. Courtney Combs, District 54
  • For State Representative, Rep. Bill Coley, District 55
  • For State Representative, Tim Derickson, Candidate for District 53

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Statewide issues

Engineer’s office plans rodeo, salt shortage

Press release from Butler County Engineer’s Office:

As temperatures begin their gradual descent to winter norms, BCEO snow and ice control crews are warming up for the season. Winter readiness really kicks in next week with a two-day event that will include a snow plow “roadeo” and driver safety training. Butler County Engineer Greg Wilkens notes that while preparations will be every bit as rigorous as in recent years, an old tradition is being revived to make things a little more fun for the crews.

“The Snowfighters Truck Roadeo will once again be part of our program this year,” said Wilkens. “The event was phased out many years ago and we felt that it was time to bring it back. It’s a good opportunity for our snow plow drivers to hone in on their skills, develop good safety practices, and familiarize themselves with their trucks. It also provides the means to interact with fellow drivers and work on their skills together.”

During the roadeo competition, snow plow drivers maneuver their trucks through an obstacle course designed to simulate actual winter situations. While hosted by the County Engineer’s Office, crews from other jurisdictions will also participate, including those from the townships, the City of Oxford, and Monroe.

Most of the winter readiness program will be concentrated into two days. Crews on Wednesday, November 5 will focus on truck preparation, including salt box and plow installations, cleaning, and getting them in winter condition. Supervisors will review routes and safety procedures with each driver who will then perform a dry run of their routes.

The roadeo will be held on Thursday, November 6, but that day will also include in-house training for all drivers. This training is a review for many, but there are also a few new drivers who will learn the fine details of truck safety inspection, safe driving practices, plow blade replacement, calcium fill procedures, tire chain utilization, and emergency procedures for a stuck vehicle or an accident.

“Safety” is what Operations Deputy Scott Bressler emphasized. “Safe crews practicing safe snow removal procedures so that our citizens can commute safely…..that is the bottom line.”

Plenty of Salt Now, but Shortages May Bring Difficulties

Road salt is currently in good supply at the BCEO, which maintains 275 centerline miles and 607 actual lane miles of roadway. Salt may be spread a little thinner this year however. A nationwide shortage has reduced salt supplies, dramatically increasing the price.

The BCEO awarded its salt contract last June to Cargill Deicing Technology which submitted a low bid of $51.42 per ton. That is a $22.00 increase from five years ago, but considerably less than what most agencies are paying this autumn due to the shortage. “Fortunately, we were ahead of the game and advertised our salt contract early before the ensuing shortage and skyrocketing prices. Some agencies are now having to pay over $170 a ton,” said Bressler.

The 6,000 tons of road salt now piled in the BCEO’s salt barn are enough to last through an average winter. But, says Bressler, it will be used more sparingly than in previous winters since additional salt may be hard to come by. Last year the Engineer’s Office spread over 8,500 tons of road salt, well over the 6,000 ton average. That was due to numerous small to medium snow events and a late season blizzard that dumped 10-15 inches of snow across Butler County.

Bressler stresses that the motoring public will need to be extra patient this winter. While the County has a good supply of salt at present, other jurisdictions around the region have not fared so well. “Regardless of where motorists are driving, we hope they will keep in mind that road salt is in short supply. We and most agencies will be spreading it thinner this year,” Bressler said. “While everything will be done to ensure a safe commute, motorists should anticipate ahead of time that roads may be a little trickier to navigate.”

Bressler also emphasized that the County may have to resort to using grit or slag, which is a small angular stone — good for traction but, of course, contains no melting properties. Some other local and regional agencies have indicated that they may use sand in place of salt should their supplies dwindle.

Winter Tips for Motorists

More patience will be required when navigating snow- or ice-covered roads this winter as motorists are urged to keep in mind the limited salt situation. In addition, commuters should always plan ahead, allow plenty of extra driving time, and if possible, stay off the roads during the most severe winter storms. More traffic makes it harder for plows and salt trucks to clear the roads. If you are stuck in traffic, so are the snow plows.

Remember, allow the plow drivers to do their job. Always be courteous and give the trucks plenty of space. Don’t pass a plow unless absolutely necessary and don’t assume the plow operator can see you.

When clearing your driveway, please do not push snow into the road. This illegal practice constitutes obstruction of the roadway and can be dangerous to motorists.

For these and other tips, plus lots of interesting information about snow and ice control, be sure to visit the BCEO Snowfighters page here on our web site.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Transportation

Poll: College students plan to vote - for Obama

See below. Now my question: Is this a surprise to anyone?

Press release from Miami University:

OXFORD, Ohio - According to a new national poll, 98 percent of Miami University students surveyed are registered to vote, 87 percent of them say they plan to cast a ballot, and 59 percent of them plan to vote for Barack Obama compared to 37 percent for John McCain.

Students at Miami and 12 other universities throughout Ohio are part of a youth election vote poll conducted by CBS News, The Chronicle of Higher Education and UWIRE, a wire service that provides news to college campuses. At Miami, 356 students responded to the poll. The online survey also included students from three other battleground states; Pennsylvania, North Carolina and Colorado.

Of the nearly 25,000 students polled at four-year colleges and universities, more than 60 percent in each state (61 percent in Ohio) preferred the Obama-Biden ticket to McCain-Palin.

In line with the total Ohio results, the economy is the most important concern for Miami students with 94 percent saying it’s an extremely to very important issue. As economic issues dominate the rhetoric on the campaign trail, a large majority of all the students surveyed (61 percent in Pennsylvania and Colorado, 56 percent in Ohio and 58 percent in North Carolina) said Obama had the best plan to resolve the country’s economic woes. Between 23 and 28 percent said McCain had the better economic plan.

“The students appear to be highly engaged with the 2008 campaign,” said Bryan Marshall, associate professor of political science at Miami and an American Political Science Association Congressional Fellow for 2008-09. “Their concerns on issues seem to parallel national trends, especially reflecting concerns over the economy. And the poll suggests that the young relate disproportionately better to Obama as compared to McCain, appear to trust Obama more to deal with the major issues, and think that Obama can deliver change more so than McCain.”

Miami students surveyed, like their Ohio counterparts, rated Obama more highly than McCain on all but one candidate quality measured in the poll. For example:

  • Is someone you can relate to: Obama, 62 percent/ McCain, 32 percent
  • Would bring about real change: Obama, 69 percent/ McCain, 37 percent
  • Effective commander in chief: Obama, 46 percent/ McCain ,79 percent
  • Cares about people like you: Obama, 76 percent/ McCain, 47 percent
  • If elected, will make a difference in your life for the better: Obama, 47 percent/ McCain, 27 percent
  • Will improve the image of the U.S. in the world: Obama, 67 percent/ McCain, 22 percent

As for the vice presidential candidates, 49 percent of Miami students surveyed said they “don’t much like” Palin compared to nearly 18 percent who responded that they “don’t much like” Biden.

As for party affiliation, Miami respondents self-identified as 37 percent Republican, 36 percent Democrat and 26 percent Independent. Thirty-two percent said their political philosophy is liberal to 43 percent being moderate and 24 percent as conservative.

Pollsters contacted 1,000 Miami students randomly and had a 35 percent response rate. For complete results of the Miami student survey, contact Linda Robertson at (513) 529-7595 or linda.robertson@muohio.edu. For complete results of the four-state survey, click on http://www.cbsnews.com/htdocs/pdf/081027_uwire.pdf.

Permalink | Comments (1) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Zettler stands by claims

I just received the below release from Jack Zettler, Democratic candidate for Butler County Auditor. Here is an overview of the issue he’s talking about.

What do you think?

Permalink | Comments (4) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Rally to focus on immigration

Press release from the Intercommunity Justice and Peace Center:

From 5:00 pm to 6:00 pm on Wednesday, October 29th a solidarity rally will be held near the Butler County Jail, 705 Hanover Street in Hamilton, Ohio. Some of those gathered will be fasting in solidarity with 100 people fasting in La Placita Olvera in downtown Los Angeles. The purpose of the fast and solidarity rally is to call on people running for political office to take a stand for comprehensive reform of United States immigration law to include a path for immigrates to live and work legally in this country.

“We are gratified to see the results of the recent poll done by the University of Cincinnati Institute for Policy Research showing that 56 % of the people of Ohio and more in Southwest Ohio, favor allowing undocumented people to stay in the US with the possibility of becoming citizens,” states Sr. Alice Gerdeman, a rally organizer. “The Butler County Jail was chosen as a spot for the rally because it serves as a detention center for undocumented people being held by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE),” continues Sr. Alice.

For more information about the fast in Los Angeles go to http://fastforourfuture.com. Petitions supporting the fasters and calling for immigrant rights will be available at the rally.

The October 29th event is sponsored by the Intercommunity Justice and Peace Center.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Butler County Sheriff's Department

Paper or digital?

The days of presidential races being called in the early evening on Election Day are far over. And in Ohio, it may be later than ever.

Due to concerns over the trustworthiness of voting machines (including problems that occurred in Butler County during the March primary), Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner is letting voters decide if they want to use a machine or a paper ballot. Just let them know at your polling place when you get there.

But they plan to count the paper ballots after the machines have been tallied. If a lot of people opt for paper, it could be a long night.

Which do you plan to use? Go here to vote and see the results of our online poll.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Joe the Plumber greeted as rock star in Middletown

Below is a summary of Joe “The Plumber” Wurzelbacher’s visit to Middletown today. My question: Do you relate to Joe the Plumber? Why or why not?

But first, here is the McCain campaign’s “I’m Joe the Plumber” commercial:

And here is a copy of the video where Wurzelbacher made his premier.

Now the story:

MIDDLETOWN — In less than a month, Joe “The Plumber” Wurzelbacher has gone from obscurity to political rock-stardom. And he went on tour Tuesday, Oct. 28.

A crowd at S&S Pools on the edge of Middletown chanted “Joe, Joe” as he emerged from a bus as an official surrogate for Sen. John McCain’s presidential campaign.

But celebrity has its curses: media scrutiny found some call excessive found Wurzelbacher is unlicensed and owes back taxes.

And as he spoke to the Middletown crowd, a state investigation started on why state computers were used to find personal information on Wurzelbacher.

“I hope they punish somebody, because I want other Americans to be able to come out and question somebody without being railroaded,” Wurzelbacher said.

Wurzelbacher walked onto the national stage when Sen. Barack Obama told him at a rally he wanted to “spread the wealth around,” and became household name when he was mentioned dozens of times during the final presidential debate.

McCain pointed to the Toledo man as an example of the middle-class worker who would be hurt economically by an Obama presidency, though Wurzelbacher likely would fare better under Obama’s tax plan because it calls for no tax increase for working couples earning less than $250,000 a year — Wurzelbacher himself earns far less — and provides for a middle-class tax cut.

His main message in Middletown was for people to get informed and vote for the American dream of small business ownership.

Wurzelbacher was followed by other business owners featured in a commercial, as well as Cathy Shepherd, owner of S&S Pools.

Shepherd said she wants to open a second store, but won’t be able to afford it under Obama’s tax plan.

“I don’t want to give a man the opportunity to take my wealth and put it where he wants to put it,” she said. “That’s not his choice, that’s my choice.”

Roughly 50 people turned out to the rally, including Joe “The Extrusion Specialist” Hall and his family from Middletowm. “We just wanted to come out here and support Joe and everything he is doing for a good cause,” Hall said.

Dorothy Colwell, also from Middletown, said the campaign owes Wurzelbacher. “He got a question answered that we all want to know,” she said.

But the controversy around Wurzelbacher continued. At Wurzelbacher’s first speaking engagement Tuesday in Columbus, he agreed with a McCain supporter who said “a vote for Obama is a vote for the death of Israel.”

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Dems’ changing Ohio strategy includes Butler County

I stumbled across an interesting story from the Web paper the Washington Indpendent. It’s an interesting take on Sen. Barack Obama’s 88-county strategy in Ohio.

It’s been said before that Gov. Ted Strickland won because he didn’t cede a corner of the state, which is exactly what John Kerry did in 2004 when he focused only on large cities.

Writes author Sridhar Pappu:

COLUMBUS, Ohio — A few days back, I was in the basement of the statehouse standing on a large map of Ohio, complete with its 88 counties, etched in the floor’s marble. I walked southwest and stood on Butler, a conservative red-meat county where I was born and my parents still live. It was home, or at least a representation of it. But looking over the remainder of Ohio seemed like staring at a foreign land, whose terrain, interests, habits and ways of life could be as far removed from life in Butler County as Zaire.

To really understand Ohio, you need a far-reaching anthropological knowledge that few possess. Sometimes, people “get it.” This would most certainly include the presidential campaign of Sen. Barack Obama, now engaged in an all-out assault to win the state’s 20 electoral votes.

Obama’s forces have hunkered down in every part of Ohio, including the more conservative southwest and southeast regions. That’s not what Sen. John Kerry’s team did four years ago when it focused on only the state’s three largest cities — Cincinnati, Cleveland and Columbus. Today, in areas where Democratic volunteers haven’t been seen by voters in a generation, the party has field offices with paid staffers numbering in the hundreds. Two weekends ago, Obama volunteers knocked on the doors of 340,846 homes. The farthest distance separating Obama field offices is 38 miles. It is an unprecedented effort to win over a highly unconventional state.

Read the whole article here.

I can attest that the Obama campaign has quite a few boots on the ground here in Butler County, a county that previous Democratic campaigns have simply deemed too Republican to enter. I have personally met half a dozen paid operatives here (though I don’t know how many are based here).

I can only imagine how many there are in Cleveland. Then again, the campaign has no shortage of money.

Sen. John McCain’s campaign has only a couple paid staffers on the ground, far as I can tell. But they have a reason for this: they say while Democrats have to pay people to work for them, Republicans have a volunteer corps the left can only dream of. This may be hyperbole, but there’s no question that GOPers have a volunteer army.

Who do you think is running a more effective campaign in Ohio? McCain or Obama?

Permalink | Comments (3) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Meet Joe the Plumber

Joe the Plumber is on tour and will meet Butler County residents Tuesday, Oct. 28, at S & S Pools in Middletown, 41 Oxford State Road.

Joe Wurzelbacher is traveling with former congressman and White House budget director Rob Portman as part of a statewide tour supporting Sen. John McCain’s presidential bid.

The two will speak briefly at 2:15 p.m., according to campaign officials, then will be available for people to meet.

Wurzelbacher achieved international fame when he was mentioned more than 20 times in the last presidential debate this year. He raised from unknown Ohio plumber to an icon for conservatives when he confronted Sen. Barack Obama about his tax plan. Wurzelbacher said he wants to buy the plumbing company he works for and asked the Illinois senator why he wants to raise his taxes if he does so.

Here is the famous exchange from ABC News:

Can you relate with Joe the Plumber?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Fairfield mayor questions Obama’s citizenship, pride in middle name

Fairfield Mayor Ron. D’Epifanio was the opening speaker at a meeting of local business leaders and surrogates for Sen. John McCain’s presidential campaign this morning.

Those surrogates were former congressman and White House budget director Rob Portman and Lady Lynn Forester de Rothschild, heiress to the Rothschild fortune.

D’Epifanio started by saying he’s not very politically correct. Then he said he is proud of his middle name — Achillo — unlike one Sen. Barack Hussein Obama.

D’Epifanio then said his father was from Italy, but he can prove he is an American citizen — “I don’t know that we have a presidential candidate that can do that,” he said.

When asked if he was suggesting Obama isn’t an American citizen, he said there is some question about whether the Illinois senator was born in the United States.

According to The LA Times, here is Obama’s birth certificate from Hawaii.

If given more time, D’Epifanio said he would have called Obama a socialist.

Permalink | Comments (1) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Sheriff tops Reynolds, Zettler in campaign spending — opponent doesn’t file

In case you missed it, we had this analysis in our paper today of campaign contributions to the two campaigns for county auditor.

It includes an illustration of how badly Democrats want this seat. The state party has pumped more than $30,000 in in-kind contributions to replace Republican Roger Reynolds with Democrat Jack Zettler. Plus the local party has infused another $35,000.

Here are copies of both candidates’ campaign finance forms. See who donated. First Reynolds:

Now Zettler:

The finance forms revealed how un-epic some other local races are. County Commissioner Charles Furmon, for example, is spending a fraction of what he did against his primary challenger and still far outspending his Democratic challenger, Butch Hubble.

But the biggest disparity came in the sheriff’s office race. Sheriff Richard K. Jones has a war chest of nearly a quarter-million dollars and has spent $49,089. His challenger, Dale Richter, didn’t file a report. It’s required under state law for any candidate who raises and spends at least $1,000.

Read more about that and other key races — including a big-spending Democratic incumbent for judge — in this analysis.

Then come back here and tell me what, if anything, you think all these dollars and cents tell you about these races.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

New elections official says GOP trying to suppress turnout

The newest and youngest Democrat on the Butler County Board of Elections says recent Republican cries of voter fraud are desperate efforts to suppress Democratic turnout on Nov. 4.

“We cannot let what happened in 2000 and 2004 happen,” said Matt Von Stein. “We cannot let the Republicans steal the election again.”

Von Stein, 31, officially joined the board Oct. 10. The Butler County Democratic party appointed him to replace Jack Zettler’s seat after Zettler stepped down to run for county auditor.

Von Stein said he believes local Republicans have been fair throughout the election process. But he criticized lawsuits on the state and national level challenging the solvency of a voter registration organization and accusing Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner of not complying with federal election law.

“What they’re trying to do is discourage people from getting out to vote,” Von Stein said.

Judy Shelton, a Republican on the board, said she had no problems with the GOP’s challenges of Brunner. “I certainly don’t know of any Republicans trying to stifle the election,” she said.

“I feel our voters have a right to question,” she said. “I have no problem with the fact we have individuals who are concerned, but I feel proper efforts are being made to ensure this is an election we will not have any doubts about.”

She also said she looks forward to serving with Von Stein on the board.

Board of election in Ohio consist of two Democrats and two Republicans. Board members make $16,483 and their job is to oversee local elections. Von Stein will serve the remainder of Zettler’s term, which expires in 2010.

Von Stein is a Hamilton electrician and president of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 648. He was elected as chairman of the local party in August. The former chairman resigned after a drinking and driving arrest.

Permalink | Comments (2) | Post your comment | Categories: Board of Elections

See what your neighbors gave to McCain, Obama

If presidential campaigns were decided solely on who could raise the most money, Sen. Barack Obama would have it bought and paid for.

But while the Democrat has raised nearly twice as much as Republican Sen. John McCain on the national stage, the advantages are reversed in this region.

In all Zip codes beginning with 450 — an area in Ohio that stretches west to Waynesville, North to Carlisle and south past Fairfield — individuals have contributed $695,993 all the presidential campaigns so far.

Of this, $288,201 went to McCain and $172,956 went to Obama.

Nationally, Obama has shattered fund-raising records with a $603.2 million war chest, compared to $332.9 million raised by McCain’s campaign.

And across the state, the two are in a near dead-heat, each raising roughly $5.5 million.

All of this information is available in an interactive (though not always functional) map on the Federal Election Commission Web site.

The map allows you to drill down and see the names, vocations, city or township of residence and contribution amount of every contributor in your Zip code.

Check it out. Notice any trends? Why do you think there’s such a difference in fund-raising amounts on the national, state and local level?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

MU study: Civic involvement going up, likely not staying up

Press release from Miami University:

The first report card on Ohio’s civic engagement efforts shows a projected major decline in political activism following the Nov. 4 election.

Ohio’s civic health index, measured by the Harry T. Wilks Leadership Institute at Miami University and The National Conference on Citizenship (NCoC), was released earlier today during a news conference at the Statehouse in Columbus. It shows nearly 59 percent of Ohioans surveyed say they are not likely to act on issues raised during the 2008 political campaigns after the election is over. Eighty-two percent of Ohio respondents say the government is not run with their interests in mind.

Report authors analyzed data from two online samples: one composed of 437 Ohioans and another of 1,000 respondents from around the country.

“The federal government takes the lead in providing a picture of the nation’s economy, but there is no centralized source of information about the condition of America’s civic health,” said David Smith, director of NCoC. “NCoC’s 2006 report documented a 30 year-long decline in the nation’s civic health. This year we’re seeing increased levels of citizen activity surrounding the presidential election, but the challenge will be capitalizing on and maintaining post-election engagement, particularly among young people.”

Miami University researchers were encouraged by certain findings, such as Ohio millennials (ages 18-29) who were positively engaged in their communities. On some indicators they lead the way in solving community problems. Fifty-nine percent of millennial citizens surveyed had volunteered in the last year, as compared with 46 percent of Generation X (ages 30-44), 44 percent of baby boomers (ages 45-64) and 32 percent of seniors (age 65 and older).

Consistent with the findings of the national report, African-American Ohioans are at least as involved, and often more involved, than white Ohioans in a range of civic activities. Sixty-three percent of African-Americans reported that they participated in at least one community involvement activity, whereas 49 percent of white Ohioans did. African-Americans also reported higher participation in political activist activities.

Other findings include bipartisan agreement on several issues:
  • 86 percent of respondents say they support giving every young person the opportunity to earn tuition money by completing a year of national community service.
  • 82 percent favor a national deliberation on major issues and requiring Congress to respond to citizen feedback.
  • 75 percent of Ohio respondents would like to see service learning (combinations of classroom learning and community service) required in schools.

According to the report, Ohio ranks 24th in the nation overall for its civic health index. The report also finds that 54 percent of those who are registered actually voted in the last three elections. About 70 percent of Ohioans are registered to vote, which means less than 40 percent of Ohio’s eligible population typically votes in a general election.

Thirty percent of Ohio respondents volunteer, which beats the national average of 26.4 percent, however, 9 percent attend public meetings, ranking below the national median.

“It is said that Ohio is a bellwether in national presidential elections, but the state’s civic health indicators are also representative of some of the nation’s strengths and weaknesses when it comes to the involvement of citizens in their communities,” said Kathleen Knight Abowitz of Miami’s Wilks Leadership Institute. “In short, Ohio can provide insight into some of the key national trends and problems.”

Beginning this year, the U.S. Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey will partner with NCoC to expand the range of information it collects in relation to the civic engagement of American citizens. As these data become available annually, they will permit NCoC and its state partners to improve measurement and to routinely monitor the civic condition of the nation and the states.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Update: Spoke too soon in celeb visit

Reports (by me) that Patricia Heaton from Everybody Loves Raymond is coming to Fairfield were premature, it seems.

Heaton is one of seven celebs and politicos the GOP is deploying across the tri-state as part of the Straight Talk Express bus tour next week, according to Republican sources.

The others are:

  • Former Massacusetts Gov. Jane Swift
  • U.S. Rep. Marsha Blackburn, R-Tennessee
  • Lady Lynn Forester de Rothschild, heiress to the Rothschild fortune
  • Sandra Froman, president of the National Rifle Association
  • Rob Portman, former congressman and budget director of the Bush White house
  • Betty Montgomery, Ohio chair of Women for McCain

Here’s what we do know: There will be a business owner’s roundtable at Jungle Jim’s International Market at 10 a.m. Monday, Oct. 27, to be hosted by Fairfield Mayor Ron D’Epifanio

Seats for business owners are filled, but the public wil be invited to a meet and greet.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Home value appraisals for prominent Dems and GOPers

Below are the appraised values this year and the values last year of the homes of prominent local Democrats and Republicans, according to the Butler County auditor’s Web site. This is in light of claims by auditor candidate Jack Zettler that values are being fixed by incumbent Roger Reynolds to benefit the Republican and his allies.

Name/ Title/ Party/ 2007 value/ 2008 value

  • Charles Furmon/ County commissioner/ R/ $216,850/ $238,590
  • Gregory Jolivette/ County commissioner/ R/ $255,560/ $251,460
  • Donald Dixon/ County commissioner/ R/ $259,810/ $251,640
  • Roger Reynolds/ County auditor/ R/ $536,480/ $535,200
  • Nancy Nix/ County treasurer/ R/ $287,740/ $247,500
  • Robin Piper/ County prosecutor/ R/ $146,080/ $138,910
  • Gregory Wilkens/ County engineer/ R/ $191,300/ $211,930
  • Richard Burkhardt/ County coroner/ R/ $285,560/ $261,030
  • Danny Crank/ County recorder/ R/ $123,380/ $139,510
  • Cindy Carpenter/ Clerk of courts/ R/ $328,110/ $297,360
  • Tom Ellis/ GOP chairman/ R/ $218,000/ $212,820
  • Ed and Judy Shelton/ City councilman and Republican leader/ R/ $467,050/ $900,360
  • John Holcomb/ Democratic leader/ D/ $199,160/ $175,750
  • Jack Zettler/ County auditor candidate and Democratic leader/ D/ $371,320/ $417,880
  • Daniel Gattermeyer/ Hamilton Municipal Judge/ D/ $296,230/ $293,830
  • John Boehner/ U.S. Congressman/ R/ $464,110/ $492,160
  • Catherine Stoker/ West Chester Twp. trustee/ D/ $216,860/ $218,300

What do you think?

Permalink | Comments (5) | Post your comment |

Clarifying claims in muddy auditor race

The following story is in our paper today — what do you think? Who do you believe?

BUTLER COUNTY — Democratic challenger Jack Zettler claims that incumbent Butler County Auditor Roger Reynolds lowered his taxable property values while raising them for many other homeowners and tried to cover it up when Zettler caught wind of it.

Reynolds vehemently denies this and says Zettler’s claims prove he is unfit for the job of auditor.

Zettler, running against Reynolds in the Nov. 4 election, made his claims about Reynolds’ conduct in a flier that hit mailboxes across the county last week. Reynolds responded with a letter demanding Zettler stop making such claims or face a lawsuit.

Here are the facts: The auditor’s office has Reynolds’ home at 6724 Cherry Laurel Drive in Liberty Twp. appraised at $535,200. This is a decrease of $1,280 from its 2007 value.

Of the 50 homes in Reynolds’ neighborhood, his was one of 11 that decreased in value, according to the auditor’s office. The rest increased.

But this is an increase of $87,700 from the $447,500 Reynolds paid for the house in April. Reynolds said he bought it from a broker and it was on the market 240 days before the purchase. The house previously sold for $591,500 in November 2007.

The house Reynolds moved out of, at 7306 Pebble Creek in Liberty Twp., which he still owns, went up $28,080 to $218,310, according to the auditor’s office appraisal records. And a house at 708 S. Main St. in Oxford that Reynolds said he owns with his brother ballooned $96,500 in taxable value to $201,630.

Home values in Oxford have skyrocketed in recent years as increasing numbers of people subdivided and rented rooms to students at a profit, according to officials with Tyler Technologies, the agency that conducted the appraisal.

Zettler’s home at 1301 Briarwood Drive in Hamilton went up $46,560 to $417,880, according to auditor’s office records. Auditor’s office staff said this is partly because his home is recorded as farmland because he breeds horses, and a change in state rules caused all agricultural properties to increase in value.

Other properties owned by the Hamilton attorney went down in taxable value.

Of the 10 parcels listed in Zettler’s name on the auditor’s office Web site — all in Hamilton — the appraised value of five was reduced by a total $12,190. However, the total taxable value of Zettler’s properties increased from $2.9 million to $3.3 million.

So both candidates saw decreases on some of their properties and increases on others. And like the average homeowner in Butler County, Zettler and Reynolds saw the taxable value of their houses go up while sale values dropped.

Zettler: Reynolds gave ‘sweet deals’ to political friends

Zettler also claims Reynolds gave a sweet deal to his Republican supporters and allies.

But a review of Butler County auditor’s office tax records for houses owned by prominent Republicans found that some went down in value, and others went up. The same is true for prominent local Democrats.

Zettler’s flier singled out Butler County Commissioner Gregory Jolivette, whose home at 520 Oakwood Drive in Hamilton dropped $4,100 to $251,460. Meanwhile, two neighboring properties with similar homes on them went up 20 percent in value.

“That is a sweet deal for Mr. Jolivette and a sour deal for his neighbors,” Zettler said. “Our postcard shows the homes. There appears to be little difference in the type of home involved. Readers should take a look and judge for themselves.”

Auditor’s office officials responded that 27 of the 37 houses in Jolivette’s subdivision went down in value. They said the homes that went up in value were thousands of square feet larger than Jolivette’s.

Jolivette also pointed out that the taxable value of his hot dog drive-in Jolly’s went up $17,970.

Jolivette said he is infuriated by Zettler’s claim and that the Democrat “may have set the record for a new low.”

“He has until Election Day to publicly apologize to me, and after that he might as well not waste his breath because it’s not going to mean anything,” Jolivette said. “I will continue to have complete and utter disrespect for his character.”

Reynolds said Zettler’s claims “crossed a legal line.”

“There are no ‘deals,’ ” Reynolds said. “Zettler’s claim is without merit and crosses into libel.”

Other local leaders who saw decreases to their home values include Hamilton Municipal Court Judge Daniel Gattermeyer. The value of the Democrat’s house went down $2,400 to $293,830. John Holcomb, former chairman of the Democratic Party in Butler County and the only Democrat on the Butler County Board of Elections, saw the value of his house drop $23,410.

While some Republicans’ house values went down, as Zettler alleges, others went up, including County Commissioner Charles Furmon, whose house is appraised at $238,590, a $21,740 increase.

“I never said every one of his political allies got a break, neither have I said that every well-known Democrat got an increase,” Zettler said. “I just know that the average homeowner in Butler County had to live with unfair appraisals.

“I believe Reynolds could have done more to fight the unfairness,” Zettler said. “I would have not certified the flawed appraisals.”

The average home in Butler County went up 5.95 percent in value this year in the tentative appraisal approved by the state in September. Reynolds said his staff will review the property values of anyone who contests them by the end of November and has lowered many values already.

Appraisals are based on many factors, according to auditor’s office staff, including sales of comparable homes in 2006 and 2007, square footage, condition of the property and attractiveness of the neighborhood to potential buyers. Officials said they used the same criteria for appraising homes this year that they have in previous years.

Reynolds explains info change

Zettler also claims that Reynolds tried to cover up the effort to lower his property value.

Zettler’s campaign captured an image on Sept. 23 from the auditor’s office Web site that shows a decrease of $20,720 on Reynolds’ new house. The value was changed on the site Oct. 6, days after Zettler publicly challenged Reynolds about his property value drop.

Deputy Auditor Michael Tilton said the wrong property valuation information was on the auditor’s Web site for thousands of homes on Sept. 23, and it was changed Oct. 6 to clear up misconceptions by Zettler and others.

All of this stems from problems the Butler County auditor’s office had with appraising residential incentive districts (RIDs), Tilton said. In these districts, created by local governments, home values are split into two values to allocate more money to local townships.

Reynolds home is in a RID, and part of his home value is locked at $499,740 while the other part goes up or down with the market. That other part was down $20,720 on Sept. 23.

The auditor’s office appraises all homes using two approaches: cost of construction and market value. But only one of these factors was taken into account when letters went out on Sept. 19 to owners of property in residential incentive districts, Reynolds said. He said a second letter had to be sent to 1,223 property owners on Oct. 6 clarifying this.

By Sept. 23, the appraisal company, Tyler Technologies, Inc., hadn’t updated the information on the site, and that info was wrong on all 2,488 parcels in RIDs in Butler County, Tilton said.

He and Louis Caldwell, Ohio area manager for Tyler Technologies, said Reynolds’ property value had never changed from $535,200, the amount based on market research.

“If he (Reynolds) had not been in a RID district, we would not have this issue,” Tilton said.

Tilton said the property values on the Web site are tentative, and often change when someone contests a value or when there’s an error.

“That amount could go up and down up and down 20 times over the entire reappraisal process,” he said.

Tilton said he started receiving numerous phone calls from Butler County residents complaining that property value notices they received by mail differed from property values listed on the auditor’s Web site. He also got calls about Reynolds’ property dropping in value.

So Tilton combined the locked property value and the value that changed for houses in residential incentive districts into one amount on the Web site to clear up any confusion.

But Zettler questions whether the auditor’s office tried to correct its mistake on Oct. 6, or cover its tracks.

“I believe that taxpayers should be very concerned about their increase when taxman Reynolds treated himself to a nice reduction, then denies the fact and tries to hide the public record when he’s caught red-handed, then changes that public record to his political benefit,” Zettler said.

Reynolds admits there were mistakes made by the appraisal firm. But the only involvement he had was to direct the auditor’s staff to lower values for all homes as much as possible, Reynolds said.

“The appraisal process has been ongoing for almost three years and was virtually complete when I took office this past April,” Reynolds said. “I have never influenced even one property’s valuation.”

Permalink | Comments (8) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Foreclosure prevention plan gaining interest

I just received a phone call from a Trenton man fearing he could lose his house. He asked about a plan Butler County is looking into to help save people from foreclosure by buying homes from banks and selling them back to homeowners. Read an overview here.

He’s not alone in his predicament. Another story that ran earlier this week included a Middletown family in the same situation. It also featured concerns some local leaders had with how the program would be implemented. They don’t want to keep people in a home they can’t afford, for example.

The Trenton man isn’t the only one with eyes on the plan, either.

This story is from Columbus-based Ohio News Network:

Paul Barker is not a happy guy. He is not losing his home to foreclosure but his owner is. Barker rents apartments and during the past few years he’s had to pack up his belongings and move.

“This is my third move, fourth move because house is being foreclosed,” said Barker.

Barker heard about a new program Butler County is working on that may help homeowners facing foreclosure. He hopes it works. And so do officials.

“If we could help a small amount of people save their home I think we’ll be happy,” said Butler county Recorder, Danny Crank.

Butler County recorder Danny Crank said thanks to $4.2 million from the U.S. Housing and Urban Development Department some homeowners may avoid foreclosure.

Under the new Neighborhood Stabilization Program, county officials want to buy houses from banks then sell them back to homeowners.

“If we could help a small amount of people save their home I think we’ll be happy,” said Crank.

To help prevent that Butler County commissioner Greg Jolivette says there are non profit programs like Neighborhood Housing Services to help people with foreclosure questions and financing solutions.

“Double edge sword because we don’t want to help people give them false hope…only to have them fall back into foreclosure two or three months down the road,” said Jolivette.

Officials said part of the money will also be used to tear down old buildings in an effort to give run down neighborhoods a face lift.

“Blighted areas demolition probably see more in city of Hamilton and Middletown,” said Jolivette.

This year there have been 1700 foreclosures in Butler County, but with a new program on the horizon, officials hope that number is a lot less in 2009.

What do you think of the plan?

Permalink | Comments (1) | Post your comment | Categories: Butler County

GOP opens Middletown office

The Butler County Republican Party has opened a Middletown area office located at 2 S. Central (corner of Central and Main across from Rogers Jewelers in downtown Middletown) to serve as the Party’s hub for election activity.

Hours for the office are Monday through Saturday from 12- 8 PM and Sunday from 12- 6 PM.

The office will have yard signs, bumper stickers and literature on behalf of the entire GOP team.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Republican Party

Boehner calls for federal pressure on Brunner

Press release from U.S. House Minority Leader John Boehner, R-West Chester Twp.:

WASHINGTON, DC - Congressman John Boehner (R-West Chester) has signed onto a letter to U.S. Attorney General Michael B. Mukasey requesting the U.S. Department of Justice use its authority to compel Ohio Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner to comply with the Help America Vote Act. The U.S. Supreme Court last week vacated a lower court ruling that ordered Brunner to provide Ohio county election officials with statewide resources to verify new voter registrations. The Supreme Court’s ruling was based on “the lack of standing of a private party to enforce HAVA’s requirements” and not on whether Brunner was acting in accordance with HAVA.

Here’s the letter:

My question: Do you think your vote will be counted properly? A lot of people don’t according to a Rasmussen poll referenced in the rest of Boehner’s statement:

“As the eyes of the nation once again turn to Ohio in this critical election, partisan politics are making a mockery of our electoral system. Secretary of State Brunner has wasted countless tax dollars and the precious little time we have before the election to fight against protecting the rights of eligible Ohio voters to cast their ballots without questioning whether their votes will count. It is imperative that every Ohioan who is eligible to vote have confidence in our system and the best way to assure voters that this election is fair is to cross-check newly registered voters maintained in the Secretary of State’s database. Secretary Brunner’s shameful partisan actions are a black eye on the Buckeye State.”

NOTE: A Rasmussen poll released last week showed that just 53 percent of Ohio voters believe their votes will be counted properly. Forty-five percent of those polled believe that people who shouldn’t be allowed to vote will do so and 28 percent said that it’s more likely that eligible voters will be denied a chance to cast a ballot. The poll also showed that 80 percent of Ohio voters believe that a driver’s license or other photo ID should be required before voting.

The Oct. 20, 2008 letter was signed by the following Ohio lawmakers: Reps. John Boehner (R-West Chester), Steve Chabot (R-Westwood), Jim Jordan (R-Urbana), David Hobson (R-Springfield), Jean Schmidt (R-Miami Township), Robert Latta (R-Bowling Green), Ralph Regula (R-Navarre), Patrick Tiberi (R-Genoa Township) and Deborah Pryce (R- Upper Arlington).

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Election night may be a mess in Ohio

From the Columbus Dispatch, a great recap of all the lawsuits, caustic accusations and even cybercrimes circulating around the Ohio Secretary of State mere weeks before the election (it’s worth noting no problems have been reported to date in Butler County):

Election night may be a mess in Ohio — By Mark Niquette

It’s Nov. 5, the day after the grueling, bitterly fought presidential election has ended and all the ballots have been cast.

But because of Ohio, no one knows whether Barack Obama or John McCain won. And the mystery stretches on for day after day after day, just like Florida in 2000.

That may not happen, of course. The race in Ohio may not be that close, or the outcome of the presidential election may not depend on who wins the Buckeye State’s 20 electoral votes.

Still, election experts say that with an Ohio Supreme Court case pending that could delay the counting of some absentee ballots, plus possible legal challenges and the potential for a large number of provisional ballots that by law aren’t counted for 10 days, there’s a growing chance an Ohio winner won’t be declared on election night.

“That risk seems increasingly larger as the days progress,” said Edward “Ned” Foley, director of Election Law @ Moritz at Ohio State University.

Those odds may be even higher for hotly contested congressional races such as the 15th District race in central Ohio, or tight legislative races that may determine which party controls the Ohio House, observers said.

But Foley and others argue that although the public and media have become conditioned to wanting a winner on election night, what’s more important is that both sides have confidence in the outcome — even if it takes awhile.

“Everybody needs to just calm down and relax,” said Bradley A. Smith, a Capital University Law School professor and former Federal Election Commission member.

There was no calming down yesterday, with the election barely two weeks away. Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner said “security breaches” caused her to shut down part of her Web site, that she had received death threats and that her office had been mailed a suspicious package covered with threatening messages and containing an unidentified powder last week. The State Highway Patrol is investigating.

Meanwhile, prosecutors in at least three more Ohio counties — Delaware, Hamilton and Hardin — are looking into possible voter-registration fraud. And while Republicans continued to allege fraud in Ohio, Democrats accused McCain of running a dishonorable campaign and the GOP of “desperate tactics.”

“It causes me to wonder, quite frankly, if there may not be an effort to set up a scenario where the Ohio outcome could be challenged,” Gov. Ted Strickland said. “I think that would be terribly unfortunate if it happens.”

At the heart of the current dispute is a disagreement about what should be done when personal information from newly registered voters doesn’t match state motor-vehicle and federal Social Security databases.

Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner has estimated that as many as 200,000 of the 660,000 Ohioans who registered since Jan. 1 have mismatches. She thinks most are the result of typos or other legitimate discrepancies, and that Ohio’s bipartisan election system has the tools to catch widespread fraud.

But Republicans sued to force Brunner to provide details about the mismatches to county elections boards as another way to correct errors and weed out fraud.

The lawsuit seeks an order that Brunner direct elections boards not to process absentee ballots unless they first are checked for voter mismatches and verified for eligibility.

Brunner tried to get the case moved to federal court yesterday on grounds it involves primarily a dispute over what federal law requires, but U.S. District Court Judge George C. Smith sent it back to the seven Ohio justices.

Lt. Gov. Lee Fisher has called for four of the justices who have financial ties to the GOP fundraiser who filed the lawsuit to remove themselves from the case. Justices Evelyn Lundberg Stratton and Maureen O’Connor, both of whom are on the ballot this fall, did so yesterday, as they have on other cases concerning the 2008 election. Justices Terrence O’Donnell and Robert R. Cupp have not.

Democrats are accusing Republicans of a coordinated effort through lawsuits and investigations of trying to intimidate new voters from casting ballots and distracting voters.

They point to Hamilton County Prosecutor Joseph T. Deters, McCain’s southwestern Ohio chairman, who subpoenaed certain unredacted voter-registration records from that county.

Deters removed himself from the investigation yesterday and a Hamilton County judge reportedly appointed Mike O’Neill, a former assistant county prosecutor, as a special prosecutor to head the investigation.

But Robert F. Bauer, general counsel for the Obama campaign, argued during a conference call that conducting investigations before an election is designed to “chill” legitimate voting.

Republicans said they’re trying to protect the integrity of the vote and defended McCain.

“It is not negative campaigning to call Barack Obama out on his partisan record, his failed judgment, or his questionable associations,” said Paul Lindsay, McCain’s Ohio spokesman.

Delaware County Prosecutor David Yost said his office is looking into two cases of potential voter-registration fraud that were referred to him by the board of elections.

One includes “a handful” of people whose registration confirmation cards were returned to the elections board because they were undeliverable.

The second involves a family of five, all of whom wrote on their registration cards that they were born on Jan. 1 but in different years.

The prosecutor’s office in Hardin County, about an hour northwest of Columbus, also is investigating possible registration fraud. No other information was available.

Dispatch staff reporter Jill Riepenhoff contributed to this story.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

In auditor’s race, it’s who you trust

I know I said there would be an exhaustive review this weekend of Jack Zettler’s claims in his quest to unseat incumbent County Auditor Roger Reynolds. I was wrong - as often happens in this industry, the story was held for further review.

My goal was to get to the bottom of what can be proven in the issue. The answer: very little. Zettler has questions and accusations and the auditor’s office has explanations. But in the end it will come down to which candidate you trust: Reynolds or Zettler.

So which do you trust?

Here is some of the story, which is now scheduled to run later in the week:

HAMILTON — It’s 2006 all over again, with Democrat Jack Zettler running for Butler County auditor and accusing the incumbent Republican of tampering with his own homes’ taxable value and doing favors for his “political buddies.”

But one thing has changed: the incumbent.

Two years ago Zettler challenged Kay Rogers. She resigned in March after pleading guilty to bank fraud. Roger Reynolds, who tried and failed to unseat Rogers in the primary election that year was appointed to replace her.

In 2006, Rogers sued Zettler. Last week, Reynolds threatened to sue Zettler if he doesn’t cease his claims.

The details of their argument are complex and center on Reynolds’ Liberty Twp. house being in a residential improvement district and the value of Reynolds’ house changing on the county auditor’s office Web site.

But Zettler’s claim is simple.

“I assume he lowered the value of his personal residence because he wanted a tax break,” Zettler said in a statement. “He changed the values of his personal residence on the Web site and therefore I don’t know if he’s changed the values of any of his other properties.”

“Interim auditor Reynolds’ actions should be viewed as deliberate, calculated and deserves official investigation by appropriate state and county law enforcement officials,” Zettler said.

And Reynolds’ response is clear: Zettler’s attack is a “fabrication”.

“Zettler is engaging in despicable politics,” Reynolds said. “He also misleads the public about my own residential property valuation process.”

A review of property values by the JournalNews found that both Reynolds and Zettler had some properties they own go up in taxable value and some go down. Both are looking at a net increase in property values, according to county records.

Increases and decreases also vary for property owned by other officials from both parties.

Questions about why property value information displayed on the auditor’s office Web site changed revealed that mistakes were made in the appraisal process and the site was changed partly to clarify Reynolds’ property value, according to auditor’s office staff.

But those officials said the mistakes applied to thousands of properties, not just Reynolds’, and though the Web site was wrong, the value of Reynolds’ property never changed.

Permalink | Comments (9) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Obama ghost hung from tree in Fairfield sparks controversy

The centerpiece of one Fairfield man’s Halloween display is a ghost hanging by a rope from a tree. The ghost is labeled “Hussain Obama.”

This has caused several of the man’s neighbors to complain. The man is not shy about his racist views: he said he believes this is a white Christian nation and shouldn’t be led by a black man, according to TV news reports.

Here is the video from local 12 news:

The city of Fairfield released a statement today:

Over the last several days, one of our residents has chosen to express his self-described racist views publicly. This individual’s isolated opinion, as depicted in a yard display, does not represent the values of our community. The elected and appointed officials of Fairfield, Ohio do not condone the actions of this individual and find this behavior abhorrent. It is unfortunate that this resident has chosen to use his First Amendment rights in this despicable manner.

For more on the role racism (and sexism and ageism) could play in this year’s presidential race, see a previous package of stories we did here.

What do you think of this display?

Permalink | Comments (5) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

County to buy, sell houses to prevent foreclosures

Help is on the way for Butler County residents facing foreclosure, county commissioners said this morning, Oct. 20. But they fear it may be too little too late.

Butler County Community Development Director Donna Everson outlined a plan to commissioners this morning to use $4.2 million they received from the federal government earlier this month.

Under the plan, homeowners facing foreclosure would deed their home back to the bank, which would then sell it to the county at 5 percent below market value. The county would then help the homeowner get affordable financing to help make the house affordable.

County leaders lauded the plan, but said there was no point in keeping someone in a house they could not afford.

“We certainly don’t want to keep somebody in a house, then two years from now they’re in the same situation they are in today,” said County Recorder Danny Crank, who offered staff to help the county find eligible homes.

Eligibility requirements include anyone making 120 percent of median income. This is roughly $79,450 a year for a family of four.

Foreclosures in the county have skyrocketed in recent years, county leaders said, totaling 1,761 foreclosures through September.

“When you think of the huge problem we have in the county, it’s not really that much money,” said Commissioner Gregory Jolivette.

The federal grant was intended to improve communities by fixing up blighted and abandoned homes and reselling. But county commissioners said that was too reactive, and they wanted to use it to keep people in their homes.

Once they do that, they will explore acquisition, rehabilitation and demolition of blighted homes.

The county money will only aid people in the county but outside the city limits of Hamilton and Middletown. Hamilton received $2.4 million under the same federal program and Middletown received $2.1 million.

The cities have until Dec. 1 to declare how they’re going to spend the money.

Permalink | Comments (1) | Post your comment | Categories: County Commission

County announces shelter schedule

After long delays in construction of a new Butler County animal shelter, county commissioners announced this week the project has a schedule for completion. Here it is (Click on the top right corner to enlarge it):

Said County Commission President Charles Furmon:

“It appears that it should be completed by the second week of April. We spent a long time getting here and we’re very frustrated, but we’re very happy to see it moving.”

How do you feel about this news?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Commission

Jolivette gives apology deadline

Butler County Commissioner Gregory Jolivette is incensed over allegations from auditor candidate Jack Zettler that Jolivette got a special deal on his property value appraisal this year.

The commissioner is demanding an immediate, public apology. Said he:

“He has until election day to publicly apologize to me and after that he might as well not waste his breath because it’s not going to mean anything…I will continue to have complete and utter disrespect for his character. I’ve spent 25 years as a public servant and never have been accused of doing something wrong. I might have someone who doesn’t like my votes or my policies but never accused me of doing something dishonest, and I won’t stand for it. It (an apology) is not going to mean a hill of beans if he does it after the election.”

Permalink | Comments (7) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Zettler answers questions on appraisal

Jack Zettler, Democratic candidate for Butler County auditor, would only answer some of my most recent questions with a prepared statement. Here are the questions and his answers:

(Go here for the background)

I understand that you are arguing that (incumbent Republican Auditor Roger Reynolds) had a lower property value then raised it after the editorial board meeting. But what proof do you have that Gregory Jolivette got any special deals or that Roger gave sweetheart deals to anyone?

RESPONSE: If two of Jolivette’s contiguous neighbors got over a 20 percent increase in tax valuation, when Mr. Jolivette got a decrease, then that is a sweet deal for Mr. Jolivette and a sour deal for his neighbors. Our postcard shows the homes. There appears to be little differences in the type of home involved. Readers should take a look and judge for themselves.

The tax value decreases realized by many of his political allies are certainly not consistent, but there are plenty of them who did get a decrease while there was an average six percent increase countywide at time real values are down significantly. Even State Representative Corky Combs said that home values in Butler County have declined 10 percent. Our interim auditor, however allowed flawed reappraisals to take effect anyway. I never said every one of his political allies got a break, neither have I said that every well known Democrat got an increase. I just know that the average homeowner in Butler County had to live with unfair appraisals. I believe Reynolds could have done more to fight the unfairness. I would have not certified the flawed appraisals. Doing it all again next year, as Reynolds plans to do, will just mean more wasted tax dollars. He should have done it right the first time.

How do you account for the fact that 5 of the 10 properties in Zettler’s name have gone down in value? As have the homes of Daniel Gattermeyer and John Holcomb, two of the most prominent local Democrats?

RESPONSE: Rogers picked and chose five of my properties that went down, but my overall increase averaged over 20 percent!

And why would Roger lower the value on his house either $1,280 or $22,720 while raising the value on his other properties a combined $123,300?

Response: I only was concerned with his personal residence. I assume he lowered the value of his personal residence because he wanted a tax break. He changed the values of his personal residence on the website and therefore I don’t know if he’s changed the values of any of his other properties. Neither do taxpayers now. I guess it is too late for anybody to find out now anyway.

Permalink | Comments (15) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Hamilton BMV hosting food drive

Press release from the Butler County auditor’s office:

A worsening economy coupled with last month’s extended power outage caused by the wind storm has left food banks stretched to the limit. In an effort to help Butler County’s Shared Harvest Foodbank replenish its shelves, the North Brookwood office of the Bureau of Motor Vehicles in Hamilton is participating in the Ohio BMV and Deputy Registrars’ 2008 Fall Food Drive.

All food and money collected locally during the drive, which runs through Dec. 1, will be directed to Shared Harvest, said Butler County Auditor Roger Reynolds, deputy registrar of the West Side office, located at 138 North Brookwood Drive.

“A donation box is set up in the BMV office for our employees and customers who want to donate,” Reynolds said. “It is completely voluntary but the food and money will be put to good use by Shared Harvest.”

According to the state Bureau of Motor Vehicles, a donation of $1 buys two meals and one pound of food equals one meal. The most needed items are canned meats, canned vegetables, canned fruit, grains (oatmeal, boxed pasta or rice), peanut butter, complete meals (canned beef, chicken, stew or ravioli), cereal and macaroni and cheese.

Office hours at 138 North Brookwood are 8 a.m.-5 p.m. on Monday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday; 8 a.m.-6:30 p.m. on Tuesday; and 8 a.m.-noon on Saturday. For more information, call (513) 737-8262.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Whose eyes are on auditor race?

The race for Butler County auditor between incumbent Republican Roger Reynolds and Democrat Jack Zettler has become both biting, and bitterly important.

Local politicos realize it’s a key position for two reasons. One, it would bring to power the only Democrat in countywide politics. Two, as (admitted felon) Kay Rogers showed us, the job can be used as a devastating political instrument. The auditor writes all the checks, and Rogers would frequently bring to light what she saw as wasteful or unethical practices (though some say only against her enemies). And, as Rogers showed, it can be misused.

Now, it appears those outside Butler County are taking notice. The mailer that Zettler sent out blasting Reynolds’ property appraisal and accusing him of misdeeds was paid for by the Ohio Democratic party. We won’t know how much the state Dems pumped into this campaign until finance reports are due next week, but those mailers aren’t cheap.

And now, today, Reynolds is an opening speaker at a rally in West Chester Twp. for Gov. Sarah Palin’s vice-presidential campaign. This is an honor usually reserved for a well-known local leader, not someone six months in office. Is this a strategy to broadcast Reynolds’ name and face across the county, particularly to the influential and right-leaning West Chester voters?

Who do you think will win this race?

Permalink | Comments (2) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

ACORN stays out of Butler County

Amid the local and national hubbub of the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now (ACORN) allegedly registering unqualified voters, Butler County elections officials say the advocacy group was not active here.

In fact, local elections officials said they’ve gone through several steps to catch voting fraud and have seen no indication of fraud to date.

One of the steps outlined in that story is not going ahead though. That step includes taking a cross-check of all new voter registrations against the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles and Social Security Administration (which the state does) and communicating it to local boards of election (which the state does not do).

Ohio Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner announced today she is appealing a ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court that would force her to communicate suspicious registrations to local boards of election.

The suit that she lost was brought by the Ohio Republican party.

Who do you think is right? Brunner or the GOP?

Permalink | Comments (1) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Reynolds, Jolivette: Zettler takes auditor’s race ‘to a new low’

Press release from the Butler County auditor’s office:

The stock market has been hit hard in recent months, but the truth is taking the worst beating of the year in Butler County. Democrat candidate Jack Zettler’s recent press release and county-wide mailer is so full of misstatements that it is possible that they don’t even contain any truths at all, other than Zettler’s name and the office for which he is running.

“It is unfortunate that, in a year of ugly campaigning, Jack Zettler may have set the record for a new low,” said Butler County Commissioner Greg Jolivette, who was included in Zettler’s attack on County Auditor Roger Reynolds. “I know Jack, and was his classmate in school. I know and very much like his family. This can’t be their proudest moment. Jack Zettler must be desperate to win office, but that’s no excuse.”

Democrat candidate Jack Zettler recently attacked Reynolds for “lowering his (Reynolds’) tax valuation”. The fact is that Reynolds owns three properties, which have risen by a total of $123,000, nearly a 15% increase. Also, Zettler tries to focus on Reynolds’ residence and claims that Reynolds realized that Zettler was on to him and then changed the property valuation to an increase in September. The fact is that Reynolds’ residential property, just like over 1,200 others in Liberty Township, was part of a “residential incentive district” that the independent reappraisal firm, CLT, was in the process of performing an updated appraisal maintenance. CLT had failed to consider market approach valuations on the RID properties, which is required, during its original reappraisal.

“Zettler wants to focus on one of three properties, and ignore the others to paint a false picture to the public,” said Reynolds. “The fact is my own total valuation increased a significant amount. Zettler is engaging in despicable politics. He also misleads the public about my own residential property valuation process. Zettler’s entire attack was a fabrication.”

Zettler went on to infer that Reynolds gives “sweet deals” to fellow Republicans on reappraisals. In reality, a solid majority of county Republican officeholders’ values increased. “The appraisal process has been ongoing for almost three years and was virtually complete when I took office this past April,” stated Reynolds. “I have never influenced even one property’s valuation. There are no ‘deals’. Zettler’s claim is without merit and crosses into libel. I have consulted with attorneys and have been assured that Zettler has crossed a legal line. That will be dealt with after this election.”

Zettler tried to use as “proof” the reappraisal of Butler County Commissioner Greg Jolivette’s residential property. According to Zettler, Jolivette received a favorable reappraisal while two neighboring properties went up in valuation. What Zettler doesn’t include is the fact that 27 of 37 properties in Jolivette’s neighborhood went down in valuation, several by more of a percentage than Jolivette’s. Zettler also fails to mention that the two homes he used in his attack do not compare to Jolivette’s in size or characteristics, which is critical to how CLT or any independent firm assesses values on property. Finally, Zettler fails to mention that Jolivette owns Jolly’s, a Hamilton restaurant, and that Jolly’s valuation went up much more than Jolivette’s personal property went down. There was obviously no “deal”.

“There is no ground for Zettler’s reckless comments. It is a total disregard for the truth,” Jolivette stated. “Zettler’s false claims are an attack on my character. People who know me, and there are many people in this county that know me, know that I would never engage in such tactics. Zettler’s attacks are so dirty and inaccurate that I challenge Jack to prove his claim now or publicly apologize and then clean up his act. I will not be used for a mudslinging campaign without some type of accountability. Jack has decided to drag my good name into the dirt in a feeble attempt to win this campaign, and it is a sadly unethical move.”

Reynolds believes his hard work to turn around a scandalized office has made Zettler bitter. “I have one thing in common with Jack; we both lost campaigns to the previous auditor. That auditor has been indicted and resigned her office, and since then I was appointed to the vacant position by the Republican Party and have achieved success in changing the tone of the Auditor’s Office. We have fought the state bureaucracy to keep property valuations as low as possible. I have promised to hold my own reappraisal next year to lower valuations for all citizens. We have put all office expenditures on-line for full disclosure, and we have cut costs and returned over a quarter of a million dollars to the community. All this was done in less than five months time. I think Jack Zettler is bitter at our success in turning things around. He has no real claims or positive vision of his own, so he makes false attacks and hides the truth. I believe Butler County is tired of these worn out, gutter politics and they want what we are offering; a fresh new start and an office that fights for the people of this county and doesn’t play dirty politics. That is the problem with Jack Zettler. There is that old cliché, ‘you don’t know jack’. Well, people are getting to know Jack Zettler well, and they don’t like what they are seeing. We now know Jack, and we know he can’t seem to tell the truth.”

Permalink | Comments (4) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Zettler’s property values went down too

A review of the recently completed taxable property value re-appraisal confirms Democratic candidate for county auditor Jack Zettler’s claim that incumbent Auditor Roger Reynolds lowered his property value.

The auditor’s office Web site shows a value increase. But the new value, $535,200, is actually $1,280 lower than the old value which is now incorrect on the site. Reynolds has an explanation for this — it’s complicated and we’ll get into it later this week — and said he had no involvement in the appraisal of his property. He also points out he bought his house for $447,500 earlier this year.

Zettler says this is all a shell game to hide his attempt to lower his values further.

What Zettler doesn’t mention is that five of his 10 properties also went down in value, according to the auditor’s office Web site. Here are the parcels and their new and old appraised values:

N. E. Street, Hamilton:

  • 2008 $1,380
  • 2007 $1,860

702 N. E Street, Hamilton

  • 2008 $83,370
  • 2007 $86,220

544 Ross Avenue, Hamilton

  • 2008 $67,080
  • 2007 $70,970

Smith Road, Hamilton

  • 2008 $520
  • 2007 $860

625 Fairview Avenue

  • 2008 $76,370
  • 2007 $81,000

Zettler isn’t alone. The only local elected Democrat, Hamilton Municipal Judge Daniel Gattermeyer, also saw a property value drop:

  • 2008 $293,830
  • 2007 $296,230

And John Holcomb, the only Democrat on the Butler County Board of Elections and former party chairman:

725 Elmwood Road, Hamilton

  • 2008 $175,750
  • 2007 $199,160

Meanwhile, the largest single increase in values went to Ed and Judy Shelton. Judy Shelton sits on the Board of Elections as a Republican and is the party’s central committee chairwoman:

625 Devanshae Court

  • 2008 $900,360
  • 2007 $467,050

To round things out, Tom Ellis, chairman of the Butler County Republican party and the final member of the Board of Elections:

1717 N Breiel Boulevard, Middletown

  • 2008 $212,820
  • 2007 $218,000

Pick up the paper this weekend for a full analysis of Zettler’s claim.

What are your thoughts?

Permalink | Comments (2) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Auditor’s race goes to the dogs

Jack Zettler’s two Dobermans, Royce and Viper, have been symbols of his campaign for Butler County auditor. He says he wants to be the Democratic watchdog of this Republican controlled county.

So Roger Reynolds, the incumbent Republican, thought he had something when he heard that the dogs weren’t licensed. He brought it up at a recent meeting where both candidates were seeking endorsement from the JournalNews.

Zettler said his dogs were licensed, just in his daughter’s name.

“The dogs are all properly licensed and there is documentation, however, the interim auditor should already have those records,” he said.

No they’re not, replied Reynolds later that day.

Dogs are licensed through the auditor’s office and, “our folks looked and Jack nor his daughter Suzanne (Zettler) have purchased dog licenses the past two years for his dogs,” he said, adding that the next auditor should lead by example.

Yes they are, replied Zettler the next day. This time he brought in what appeared to be an up-to-date license in his daughter’s married name for two Dobermans. He also brought in one of the dogs with a corresponding number on its tag.

“The interim auditor makes well over $100,000 with benefits, not counting all the vacation time he’s already taken,” he said. “Now all he wants to do is bark about a $14 dog license.”

Zettler did not allow the JournalNews to photocopy the license, however, and asked that his daughter’s name not be released to Reynolds, saying he fears she would be harassed. This made it impossible to verify the license with the auditor’s office.

Reynolds said he has no interest in pursuing the issue further. “If he’s got a dog license, that’s fine,” he said.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Crank v. Patton

In a now-familiar paradigm, the Democratic challenger, Lana Patton, for Butler County recorder is running on a campaign of change, and the Republican incumbent, Danny Crank, is running on his record.

The Democrat

Patton, 48, of Milford Twp., said she wants to put the office’s records online, possibly charging a small fee to access them.

Crank took the records down three years ago to protect residents’ sensitive information. The records are only available in his office.

Patton also said her 20 years in real estate give her the background needed to run the office, which deals mostly with recording land transactions.

“I deal with title companies day in and day out, this is what I do,” she said.

And she said Butler County government is lacking integrity.

“With all the scandals

and everything that goes on

in Butler County, it’s time to put honesty back in Butler County offices,” she said. “I think it’s time that Butler County needs to be revamped, and I think it will probably happen this year.”

The Republican

Since taking over the office eight years ago, Crank, 62, said he was the first in the state to set up electronic records filing, and has focused on customer service and thrift.

“Basically, I run a fiscally conservative office,” he said. “I don’t waste money, I got a bare-bones staff and we run everything on a very small budget.”

Crank said he renegotiated a contract last year, allowing him to save potentially $365,000 by 2010.

Crank said he’s redacting records to put them online, but it’s a slow process. Instead of paying $185,000 to have it outsourced, he has four employees looking through 2.5 million pages of documents.

In addition to identity theft concerns, Crank said he doesn’t like the idea of offshore companies doing title searches online.

“People in Butler County make a living doing research in the office,” he said. “(With records online) you don’t have to hire people in Butler County anymore. (There are) people in India who will do title searches for you for nearly nothing.”

The Butler County recorder’s office has 17 employees and an annual budget of roughly $1 million.

Permalink | Comments (2) | Post your comment | Categories: County Recorder

Combs to call for statewide property value decrease

Press release from state Rep. Courtney Combs’ office, R-Hamilton (coming on the heels of county Auditor Roger Reynolds’ similar promise):

State Representative Courtney Combs (R- Hamilton) today announced plans to introduce legislation aimed at easing the financial burden placed on homeowners due to property value reappraisal increases.

Since property reappraisals are approaching up to a 12 percent increase in some Ohio counties while homeowners are experiencing a decline in the value of their home, Combs is taking action. His proposed legislation would provide a 10 percent property value reduction for all homeowners in the 2009 tax year. This reduction would mean a homeowner whose house is appraised at $100,000 would pay property taxes as if it were a $90,000 valuation.

“Many residents are suffering with higher property taxes even when their homes are declining in value,” Combs said. “I believe decreasing the property value by 10 percent will help provide Ohio residents with some much needed relief and will allow the reappraisal numbers to catch up to their fair market value.”

Across the country many states are addressing this issue of unfair and unrealistic valuations of home values. Ohio is among the highest in foreclosures and we must ease the pain for property owners. His plan will allow for similar reductions in 2010 and 2011 if necessary. Combs hopes it will not be necessary.

“We need to protect our property owners and keep people in their homes,” Combs said. “I am very concerned about the foreclosure rates here in Ohio and across the nation.”

The legislation is currently being drafted by the Ohio Legislative Service Commission and will be introduced this month.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Statewide issues

Sarah Palin coming to Butler County this week

Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin is scheduled to visit West Chester Twp. Friday.

Here are the vitals, from this story by reporter Dave Greber:

What: Republican vice presidential nominee Gov. Sarah Palin’s first visit to Butler County.

Where: The Square of Union Centre area of West Chester, a newly built community park situated near Lakota West High School and the heavily traveled Union Centre Boulevard in West Chester Twp.

When: Gates open at 8:30 a.m., Friday, with pre-programming beginning at 10:30 a.m. Palin is expected to take the stage at 11:30 a.m.

How to go: Tickets will be required for the event, and can be picked up starting Wednesday, Oct. 15, at the Butler County GOP Headquarters, 5964 Golf Club Lane, and the West Chester office of the Friends of John Boehner, 7908 Cincinnati-Dayton Rd Suite I. Both facilities will be open from 8:30 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Furmon v. Hubble for commission

After struggling through an epic Republican primary, long-time Butler County Commissioner Charles Furmon now faces Democrat Butch Hubble in November.

Here is the story. Here are the vitals:

Furmon:

  • Age: 68
  • Profession: Retired Hamilton police officer, county commission for three terms.
  • Platform: “To do whatever I can to better the quality of life for the citizens of Butler County.”

Hubble:

  • Age: 64
  • Profession: Retired Navy officer and San Diego police officer
  • Platform: “I know for a fact that we have an abundance of resources in our area that don’t seem to be used. We have to do something; right now I’m not seeing anything done.”

There’s a lot more in the story, including specific examples of what Furmon says he has accomplished in his years on the dais and specific initiatives Hubble wants to implement.

Read the story then come back and tell me: Who has your vote?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Commission

Reynolds releases new unclaimed funds database

Just received this release from the Butler County auditor’s office:

There is over $1.5 million in unclaimed money available in Butler County. Now, citizens are a mouse click away from finding out if any of it belongs to them.

Starting today, The Butler County Auditor will post the list of unclaimed funds on the Auditor’s Web site. Over 23,000 entries exist in the database. A person visiting the site can click on the “Unclaimed Funds” icon, type in their last name, and see if they are owed any unclaimed money from Butler County.

“There are various reasons that a person might have unclaimed funds,” says County Auditor Roger Reynolds. “Forgotten bank accounts, overpayments to government entities, and unknown rebates are just a few reasons why money can be unclaimed. We are anxious to put these dollars back in the public’s hands. Hopefully, people will go to the Web site and check for their names, as well as the names of family members and friends. It may not be much money at all or it may be a substantial amount, but whatever is there rightfully belongs to that person. I want to see this money returned to citizens as quickly as possible.”

The Web site is www.butlercountyauditor.org. The “Unclaimed Funds” icon is on the home page.

Money that is found can be retrieved by contacting the Butler County Auditor or visiting the third floor of the office at 125 High Street.

Permalink | Comments (7) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

More on Zettler’s claims

Jack Zettler, candidate for Butler County auditor, just issued this press release further outlining his attack on Auditor Roger Reynolds:

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Reynolds releases hounds of his own

It appears Butler County Auditor Roger Reynolds isn’t content to stay on the defensive.

In the same JournalNews editorial board meeting (which I wasn’t in, because I am not a member of the editorial board) where Reynolds’ challenger Jack Zettler first accused Reynolds of lowering his own property values, Reynolds asked Zettler if his two oft-referenced watchdogs are licensed.

Zettler said they were in his daughter’s name. Reynolds says otherwise in this e-mail:

My phone was quick to ring today as the interview video was posted on the JN website. The video prompted me to contact you on two fronts.

First, I failed to thank you for the opportunity to interview and above all else ask for the endorsement. So I would like to thank you and let you know it would be privilege to receive your endorsement.

Secondly, I checked the records today on the dog tags. Jack nor his daughter Suzanne have purchased dog tags for the 2 doberman’s in either 2007 or 2008. He told us in the meeting that his daughter made the purchase. The next Auditor must lead by example.

Take care,

Roger Reynolds

What do you think?

Permalink | Comments (1) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Coming soon to a mailbox near you

Update: Read the whole story on Butler County Auditor Roger Reynolds’ property values (to date, at least) here and here.

Original post:

Here is a copy of the latest mailer from Democratic candidate for Butler County Auditor Jack Zettler:

Strong stuff. And completely fabricated, according to Auditor Roger Reynolds and Commissioner Gregory Jolivette.

Reynolds:

“He’s bordering on slanderous statements. I contacted an attorney yesterday. (Zettler) is not going to continue to not only insult me but my staff who are working their tails off to help the public during this re-evaluation. If Jack has to stoop to gutter politics and lying to win, shame on him.”

Jolivette (pointing out that the property Jolly’s sits on went up in value):

“If he’s going to be doing that kind of campaigning without checking all the facts and all the circumstances, we certainly don’t want him as auditor.”

What do you think?

Permalink | Comments (3) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Turner: ‘We never go looking for a free lunch’

In response to criticism of how much the Butler County Emergency Management Agency spends on meals at training workshops, EMA Director William Turner created the following report for County Administrator Tim Williams.

In it, Turner explains what the money is spent on, and lays out most of the recent training events (though not all, as the $900 spent at the Montgomery Inn Boathouse is not on the list). The total listed over the last 12 months: $12,554.25.

Permalink | Comments (5) | Post your comment | Categories: Emergency Management Agency

County: Layoffs only the beginning

Butler County commissioners continued cutting jobs Thursday, announcing nine layoffs in Job and Family Services and the elimination of 20 positions. Here’s the story.

As often happens in this business, the story was trimmed for length. Here are the paragraphs that didn’t make it in the paper:

Some of these programs are already underfunded, (Job and Family Services Deputy Director Jerome) Kearns said, and more cuts will eventually impact service delivery.

“The needs of our community are going to go higher, but the state is reducing our allocation,” said County Commissioner Gregory Jolivette.

This follows an announcement in September that 10.5 positions will be cut in Children Services, 5.5 through layoffs. And the county is still mulling whether to hire an outside agency to scour the county budget for more staff cuts.

Here are the positions that are being laid off:

And here’s where a lot of this began. If you look at the blog entries around this date, you will see the full context of the debate back then on how county employees are paid.

Do you think the layoffs are the right course of action?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Commission

EMA takes $900 working lunch

Update: Click here for a written response from Butler County Emergency Management Director William Turner to the criticisms below.

Original post:

Butler County commissioners were already varying shades of displeased with Butler County Emergency Management Director William Turner. And they are still waiting on a full report on what needs to be changed to prevent another string of mishaps as happened after Hurricane Ike hit.

So when they were asked Thursday to approve more than $1,000 in reimbursements for catered training workshops, they went off. Commissioner Gregory Jolivette:

“It seems like they say let’s go to lunch and while we’re at it, let’s have a meeting.”

Commissioner Donald Dixon:

“Based on the last performance that I saw, maybe we ought to do a little less eating and a little more training.”

Commission President Charles Furmon:

“That does sound exorbitant in my estimation.”

The reimbursements were for three training workshops. One was a $900 lunch at Montgomery Inn at the Boathouse, and two were at Washington Platform Saloon and Restaurant, totaling $344.25.

Turner said they try to keep the cost of food at these events at a minimum, but it is paid for with federal homeland security money.

Permalink | Comments (16) | Post your comment | Categories: Emergency Management Agency

Propery appraisals - another homeowner’s story

Helen Plank just called to tell me how impressed she was by how Butler County Auditor Roger Reynolds’ office responded to her concerns about how her property was appraised in this year’s controversial tax reappraisal.

We first met Helen at a town hall meeting at Ross Twp., where Reynolds suggested that the public contact his office and he can help them if they think their appraisals are too high. Here’s that number again: (513) 887-3154.

And help they did, Plank said. She owns several houses in Trenton and saw all of their taxable values reduced considerably, she said, and someone from the office spent a few days at her house pouring over the records.

Her home’s tax value originally shot from $61,000 to $116,230, she said, but the auditor’s office dropped it back to $62,500 — “there’s not a $50,000 home on my street, except for mine,” she said. Another house’s value dropped from about $52,000 to $51,000 with help from the auditor’s office, when that office originally had it at $70,000. Yet another home’s tax value dropped from $80,000 to $46,590, she said.

She said they were very responsive to her needs.

This is in sharp contrast to George Kiniyalocts, a Middletown property owner who is not pleased with the process.

Have you contested your property values? What was your experience?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Butch Hubble’s platform

Butch Hubble, the Democrat challenging incumbent Republican County Commission President Charles Furmon in November, just stopped by and dropped off this statement:

When I left here 40 years ago to begin my military service, we had public transportation like local and greyhound bus service. We had passenger trains that stopped here. Our towns had industries such as automobile manufactory, paper mills and large safe companies.

Where did it all go and why?

In the past 6 months I have traveled nearly all over this county visiting townships, villages and city councils. I have been looking around and talking to people about our economy. The attitudes and comments are remarkably similar about what we need to do to boost our economy. It was well noted that a few areas are doing quite well as far as local development goes, but most of our towns are not.

We have the resources to keep up with the rest of this country but are recourses seem to be going to waste. Our infrastructure does not make sense in a lot of places. We have 45 percent of our traffic traveling on 3 percent of our roads. We build large malls and forget about the needs of small businesses.

One would assume the people in Hamilton, Ross or Millville as examples would want to shop in the large department stores. But if they do not have a car or know some who can give them a ride, then how are they going to get there? What is even more disturbing is that in a recent survey it was found that one third of family income is spent on transportation. We need to first rebuild our base and start thinking about the future a lot more.

The lack of employment is a serious detriment to the future of our county. Yet people are transported in from Cincinnati to work in our malls while we’ve got families in our county standing in the unemployment and food line every week.

I certainly have had enough of this type of government. Change is not going to happen on it’s own. We have got to do something to improve what is going on in our towns, districts and county.

As you commissioner, I will start by bringing the type of employment to our area that will affect our local pool of citizens in a positive way.

We need to move away from the traditional way of thinking by bringing in fresh minds to help repair and rejuvenate our torn economic base.

We can start the fix now. But we can’t do much if we stay with the same old routine. It is well known that if you do the same things over and over you will get the same results. We need new-experienced leaders that will bring innovative methods to lead us up and out of these hard times.

I will work to have our county take the lead in using alternative energy. I will help maintain and keep a balanced budget to work with. I will help stream line the health care services to make it more user friendly and I will work to ensure our education system is balanced through out the county.

I believe that by working as a complete team and building on the resources we have, we can create more jobs, help those who are losing heir homes and make the American dream an American reality for all people.

I am that proven leader. I bring over forty years of leadership and management to the table. I have a proven track record of success. It’s time for the old ways to step aside and let new fresh thinking and management move us forward

I will reduce the inner competition, help adjust the tax base to cause a more equal distribution of funds and focus our efforts as a team to ensure we all move forward.

Permalink | Comments (2) | Post your comment | Categories: County Commission

Judge Niehaus’ legacy

I went to the ceremony Wednesday where they renamed the county’s juvenile justice center the Judge David J. Niehaus Juvenile Justice Center in honor of the late judge.

It was a tearful occasion, and it was clear that the judge was loved and respected by many.

They presented a PowerPoint presentation based on a speech Niehaus gave some years ago. I thought it was a moving speech, so I give it to you below (click on the upper right corner to enlarge):

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Crime and courts

Reynolds v. Zettler — video

Anyone interested in Butler County politics, which theoretically should be anyone on this blog, would likely agree that the Butler County auditor’s race is one of the big ones to watch this year.

It has it all: past scandals, heavy partisanship, public unrest and continuing allegations of wrongdoing.

Here is the overview of the race I wrote.

And here are videos of the two candidates, unfiltered by the media so to speak, responding to four points:

  1. Why they are better suited for the office.
  2. “Patronage and hiring practices throughout Butler County government have been under scrutiny over the past year. Do you intend to follow past practices of fill job openings in a different manner?”
  3. “Explain what you are doing to minimize the increase in property valuation — and thus taxes — that Butler County homeowners are seeing after the reappraisal.”
  4. “What’s the biggest change you intend to bring to the auditor’s office?”

Take a look at the video them come back here and tell me: who do you think won the debate?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Judge races heating up

There are several appeals court judgeships that have been hard-fought this year — then again, most judge races are, because they’re fought between attorneys.

  • One is the race for a newly created seat on the 12th District Court of Appeals. Fairfield attorney Bruce Carter, a Democrat, and Clermont County Common Pleas Judge Robert Ringland, a Republican, are vying for that one. Here is the full story.
  • Another is the contest between former West Chester Twp. Judge Robert Hendrickson, a Republican, and Laura Curlis, Democrat and administrative assistant to the Wilmington mayor. Here is that story.

The court of appeals is rarely thought of, but is an extremely important aspect of Ohio’s judicial system.

Who do you think are the most qualified candidates?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Crime and courts

Voter rolls surge

Monday was the last day to register to vote in Ohio, and register — and vote — people did in Butler County (with a little encouragement from Cuba Gooding Jr).

The Ohio Secretary of State’s office released today the number of voters who have registered this year. It totals 665,949 statewide (bringing the total to 8,184,138 active voters) and Butler County ranked fourth in the country with 29,671 new voters (bringing the local total to 258,055).

Here are the top ten in the state (rank/county/total voters on Jan. 1, 2008/total on Oct. 6, 2008/net change):

  1. CUYAHOGA/973,831/1,096,449/122,618
  2. FRANKLIN/761,806/829,427/67,621
  3. HAMILTON/549,743/596,722/46,979
  4. BUTLER/228,384/258,055/29,671
  5. SUMMIT/345,340/374,042/28,702
  6. MONTGOMERY/354,972/382,842/27,870
  7. STARK/243,349/268,518/25,169
  8. LUCAS/286,145/310,905/24,760
  9. LORAIN/184,296/201,001/16,705
  10. CLERMONT/120,200/133,785/13,585

From Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner:

“We are already seeing the results of our preparation for November, with absentee voting a success across Ohio and 665,949 active voters added to the rolls. These are Ohioans from every corner of our state who can now take part in our democracy. Ohioans and, indeed the nation, can be confident that our preparation is yielding successful voting administration in 2008.”

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment |

Nix: County public funds are safe

In light of turmoil on Wall Street and concern over whether the recently passed federal bailout will work, Butler County Treasurer Nancy Nix issued this statement today:

County Investments/Public Funds: They Are Safe

Butler County Treasurer Nancy Nix wants to assure residents of Butler County that during the current turmoil and uncertainty on Wall Street, the County’s investments of public funds remain safe.

“Butler County’s investment portfolio is safe. We have not invested in any mortgage backed securities. Our assets have the full support and backing of the Federal Government. We have a high quality portfolio that is conservative in nature and in full compliance with investments allowed by law for public funds,” said Treasurer Nix.

Treasurer Nix explains the make up of the County’s portfolio: “Butler County’s investment portfolio contains non-mortgaged-backed, direct obligations of U.S. Federal Agency securities. Our assets are held at the Federal Reserve Bank, through a custodian bank. The primary focus for management of the County’s portfolio is protection of principal and maintenance of liquidity. At any given time, our portfolio contains access to sufficient liquidity to meet the County’s obligations.”

Management of the County’s investment portfolio will continue with a conservative and safe strategy as determined by the Investment Advisory Committee in accordance with Ohio law and the County’s Investment Policy.

On a related note, I spoke to Butler County Administrator Tim William earlier this week about how all of this effects the county. He said, in short, that it doesn’t effect Butler County as much as some other places. Said he:

“Butler County is fortunate with our bond rating (AA2)…so we’re one of the people that are not going to have problems in the future if we need to raise money via some bond or note. (and) We’ve been fortunate that we are still experiencing some commercial growth, which is offsetting the downturn.”

Are you comforted by this news?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment |

Combs v. Keith for state House

From this story on the race between incumbent Courtney Combs and challenger Ken Keith for the state House’s 54th District:

Keith criticized his opponent for going after the Butler County auditor’s position when it became available earlier this year.

“Combs was ready to jump ship in the middle of his term. Is that someone you want in the office?”

Combs said his experience in politics makes him a better candidate than Keith.

“At this point in time, it’s very essential to have people in public office that can point to their record and show what has effectively been done.”

The 54th District includes Hamilton and the surrounding environs.

What do you think?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Statewide issues

Niehaus renaming ceremony Wednesday

The Butler County Juvenile Justice Center will be renamed in honor of the late Juvenile Judge David Niehaus Wednesday, Oct. 8.

A naming ceremony is scheduled from 12:30 p.m. to 1:30 p.m. at the building, 280 N. Fair Avenue in Hamilton. It will feature speeches for elected officials, community leaders and Niehaus’ wife and son.

“This ceremony is just a small gesture to show our deep appreciation and respect for a life well lived,” said Butler County Commission President Charles Furmon. “Judge Niehaus was a leader, a friend and someone who never stopped fighting for our area children. He will be deeply missed.”

Judge Niehaus passed away unexpectedly on July 31 after serving the Butler County community for more than 40 years. During his career in Butler County, Niehaus served as a juvenile court probation officer, juvenile court referee, probate division common pleas judge, and went on to become the first juvenile court judge in Butler County.

“We are renaming the Juvenile Justice Center in honor of Judge Niehaus so that generations to come will know what an impact the judge had on our community,” said Commissioner Gregory Jolivette. “He was someone who always put his obligation to the children and families of Butler County first.”

Commissioner Donald Dixon said Niehaus, “left an everlasting impression on the Butler County community and it is only fitting that we rename the Juvenile Justice Center in his honor.”

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Crime and courts

Who will get vets’ vote?

It may not always be who you think. In this story that ran in our newspaper Sunday, writer Rick McCrabb compares how Sens. John McCain and Barack Obama are ranked by national veterans group.

Of course, veterans are far from in the bag for Obama. Here’s another story from that day on how Butler County veterans’ attitudes are split. It also includes insight from David Spencer and Keith Maupin, both of whom lost sons in the line of duty in Iraq.

Are you a veteran? Which candidate are you supporting?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Butler County outlines post-foreclosure assistance, laments lack of pre-

Butler County officials outlined last week how $8.7 million in federal dollars can aid local neighborhoods impacted by the ongoing housing crisis.

The funds are part of the recently passed Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008, which includes $2.4 million for Hamilton, $2.1 million for Middletown, and $4.2 million for the rest of Butler County.

This is good news and bad news, Butler County Community Development Director Donna Everson told county commissioners Thursday, Oct. 2, saying the dollar amount is based on how many homes in the county have experienced or are facing foreclosures.

“It’s based on the fact that we have enough that we’re getting $4.2 million to address it,” Everson said.

The money, she explained, can be used to purchase foreclosed homes, fix them up and sell them. The county can also use it to demolish or fix up blighted and abandoned homes, or establish land banks for homes that have been foreclosed upon.

The county has 18 months to develop a plan for the money, and will schedule a meeting to get public input.

“We need to find where all these homes are in the county and then develop a course of action,” Everson said.

Hamilton and Middletown officials are going through the same process.

County commissioners praised the federal relief, but lamented that it seemed more aimed at fixing areas already hurt than preventing more damage.

“This is sort of after the fact,” said Commissioner Donald Dixon. “We really need to intervene before they get foreclosed upon.”

Commissioner Gregory Jolivette asked if the county could put a freeze on the foreclosure process until the county had a plan to deal with it.

Everson said she is looking into Dixon’s and Jolivette’s concerns.

Permalink | Comments (1) | Post your comment | Categories: County Commission

Down to crunch time

In case you haven’t noticed, there’s a pretty big election going on. For any who haven’t seen it, this is our comprehensive page for all local elections stories.

Some highlights:

Any thoughts on any of these issues or races?

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Kennedy, Rove visit Butler County

Within a week, Butler County will have hosted two notable people to talk about this year’s presidential election.

The first visited New Miami on Wednesday and stumped for Sen. Barack Obama. That was Max Kennedy, the ninth son of Robert F. Kennedy. Here is the story on Kennedy’s visit.

Next Wednesday, Oct. 8, Karl Rove will speak at Miami University about the race. He does not work for Sen. John McCain’s presidential campaign, but generally supports his fellow Republican and is arguably one of the most famous political strategists of our time.

The event is sponsored by Miami University College Republicans. It begins at 7:30 p.m. Wednesday at Miami University’s Hall Auditorium. Tickets are on sale at the Shriver Center Box Office (513) 529-3200 for the general public. Tickets are free.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

Clerk candidate running on ‘change’

This weekend, we will run a story on the race for Butler County Clerk of Court. The candidates are incumbent Republican Cindy Carpenter and Democratic challenger Robert Tunnat.

Tunnat said he’s running on a campaign of change. Change what? He’s not completely sure:

“I’ve never been inside that office, so I don’t know what I’m going to change.”

So what makes him qualified for the job? He said he asked an attorney and all he needed was a high school diploma, which he has.

“As far as actual experience in anything like that, no I’ve never done anything like that before…but I know that there are people that work there now that would be able to help me along and show me the ropes as I go along.”

So why does he think people should vote for him, not his opponent?

“I’m for change, that’s about all I can think of.”

Read our paper this weekend for the full story.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Crime and courts

Zettler, state respond to appraisal plan

Both the state and the auditor’s political appointment took at least partial credit for Butler County Auditor Roger Reynolds’ plan to reappraise property values in 2009.

Here is the story, which includes support for the idea from Shelly Wilson, director of the Ohio Department of Taxation’s tax equalization division. Said she:

“It’s the auditor’s right and the auditor’s duty to value the market at market value.”

Democrat Jack Zettler, who is challenging the Republican incumbent for the seat this year, also took credit for spurring the move. Here’s his comments:

“It’s wonderful to know that someone is listening to what you’re saying in a political contest, even if that someone is your opponent. Finally our interim county auditor has reacted to the numerous statements and articles by our campaign, as well as, the hundreds, if not thousands, of statements by the county homeowners about his unfair property values. Is he really going to get off his duff and do something?

His promise seems to be, ‘I raised your property tax values in 2008 despite the fact that your real property values are decreasing, but trust me, elect me and I’ll correct it next year.’

Right about now, do you hear the words in you head: ‘Sure, taxman Reynolds, I was born, but not yesterday?” Well I do.

Quite frankly his press release would be laughable if not for the fact that so many homeowners are suffering real economic hardships that have been exacerbated by his folly.

Taxman Reynolds when it comes to property valuations, the ‘bucks stops’ at the county auditor’s door. That just the way it is. You are supposed to do it right the first time.”

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Recycling grants available

Press release from Butler County Solid Waste District:

The Butler County Recycling and Solid Waste District is now accepting applications for its 2009 Recycling Incentive Grant. The District provides funds on a competitive basis to local businesses, schools, non-profit organizations and local governments to support new recycling initiatives or the expansion of existing recycling services.

Since 2000, the District has provided grant funding to diverse organizations in Butler County. Last year, 14 organizations received grant awards worth more than $15,000. The funding has helped subsidize the cost of new recycling containers, recycling services and promotional materials — resulting in increased and sustainable recycling programs throughout the county.

Here is what some of the 2008 recipients did with their grant money:

  • Schools—Several area schools purchased recycling containers to support paper recycling programs. Through these programs, the schools generate revenue that helps sustain long-term recycling and school-based environmental activities.
  • Businesses—Aeronca Inc. began a newspaper and beverage container recycling program. Candlewood Apartments collaborated with Miami University’s Institute of Environmental Sciences to implement new recycling for apartment dwellers.
  • Nonprofits—Hamilton’s Parks and Recreation Department purchased and placed new recycling containers in its parks and golf courses.

Applicants must complete and submit their application online no later than December 12, 2008. To apply, please visit www.butlercountyrecycles.org, click on “recycling,” then “recycle at work,” and then “funding assistance.”

For more information on the grant or other recycling programs, please contact the District at (513) 887-3406.

The Butler County Recycling and Solid Waste District is dedicated to promoting recycling, waste reduction and responsible disposal of all waste from households, commercial businesses, and industry to conform to Ohio EPA regulations.

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: Butler County

The state on Reynolds bucking the state

The Ohio Department of Taxation is still mustering a response to Butler County Auditor Roger Reynolds’ claim that he is doing his own property tax reappraisal next year because the state has him handcuffed this year. See the post below for more.

But I do have what appears to be the only correspondence between Reynolds and the state on the issue, Dated Sept. 29. Reynolds said he was verbally told “no.” Here is the text of the letter:

September 29, 2008

Richard Levin, Tax Commissioner Ohio Department of Taxation

Mr. Levin,

As you are aware, counties across Ohio, including Butler, are facing a housing crisis unlike any in recent memory. Hopes of a timely housing market recovery continue to fade due to the upheaval within the banking industry. Fair it to say, our mandatory revaluation could not take place at a worse time.

As the County Auditor, I am faced with the daunting task of assessing a fair and equitable value on properties during a rapidly declining housing market. The instability in the housing market makes it impossible, at this time, to assess a fair and conservative value on residential properties.

Ohio Revised Code (ORC) 5713.01 states that “The commissioner may grant an extension of one year or less if the commissioner finds that good cause exists for the extension.” I trust that you agree such language in the ORC was meant for such an instance as we are experiencing with the current housing and banking crises.

I am asking that you exercise your authority per ORC 5713.01 and grant Butler County a one year extension to submit our revaluation. The extension will allow time for the markets to gain stability which is imperative in fairly assessing property values.

I greatly appreciate your consideration and look forward to working out an equitable solution for the citizens of Butler County.

Warmest Regards,

Roger Reynolds, CPA

cc: Shelly Wilson, Executive Administrator for Property Taxes

Here is how Butler County’s appraisal stacks up against other counties, as provided by the Department of Taxation:

Josh:

In response to one of your questions…

There are 28 counties scheduled for a triennial sales update and another 13 going through a complete six-year reappraisal this year.

As of Sept. 12 — which is the latest information available to me at this precise moment — the tax commissioner had approved tentative abstracts for 22 update and nine reappraisal counties. I’ve listed these counties below, along with the aggregate change expected in residential property value as a result of these update or reappraisal efforts.

The update counties:

  • Auglaize 6.90 percent increase
  • Darke 6.96 percent increase
  • Defiance 3.46 percent increase
  • Franklin 0.15 percent decrease
  • Gallia 5.04 percent increase
  • Geauga 0.56 percent increase
  • Hamilton 0.88 percent increase
  • Hardin 4.78 percent increase
  • Henry 4.81 percent increase
  • Jackson 4.74 percent increase
  • Mahoning 0.09 percent increase
  • Mercer 4.42 percent increase
  • Morrow 1.22 percent increase
  • Pickaway 1.29 percent increase
  • Putnam 5.08 percent increase
  • Preble 2.76 percent increase
  • Richland 0.22 percent increase
  • Seneca 5.58 percent increase
  • Shelby 2.93 percent increase
  • Trumbull 0.13 percent increase
  • Van Wert 6.37 percent increase
  • Wood 1.09 percent increase

The reappraisal counties:

  • Ashland 6.67 percent increase
  • Athens 11.51 percent increase
  • Butler 5.95 percent increase
  • Clermont 7.19 percent increase
  • Fulton 1.04 percent increase
  • Greene 7.78 percent increase
  • Knox 10.03 percent increase
  • Montgomery 0.24 percent increase
  • Summit 0.95 percent decreas

Permalink | Comments (0) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

Auditor promises appraisal reduction in 2009

Press release from the Butler County Auditor’s office:

Butler County Auditor Roger Reynolds has announced that he is taking the bold and unprecedented step on behalf of taxpayers to lower property valuations in 2009.

Reynolds has made several requests upon the State Tax Commissioner for an extension of the 2008 property reappraisal while working within the constraints of the law. The extension would allow time for the markets to stabilize. Reynolds has been consistently told no. Therefore, Reynolds is taking the matter into his own hands on behalf of county property owners.

“The state bureaucracy may not understand how this housing market affects everyday people, but I do.” Reynolds said. “At the ground level, we see and feel this crisis. In 2009, I have the authority to lower values, and I will.”

Currently, the state tax commissioner must approve valuation changes once every three years. Routinely, auditors do not exercise their right under section 5713.01 of the ORC to conduct a valuation in the off years, but Reynolds sees these economic conditions as anything but routine.

“I have seen the significant drop in sale prices this year, therefore, I am going to lower values in 2009,” states Reynolds. “Now is the time for bold leadership and decisive action to combat the housing market crisis. This year, I was handcuffed by the state but that’s not the case in 2009 - I ‘m going to do what is right for the people of Butler County.”

Reynolds was appointed in April of this year, after the reappraisal work was mostly completed. Reynolds has hosted eight town hall meetings over the past month and has four more scheduled over the next few days throughout the county. He has been working diligently to assist property owners with their reappraisal questions.

“2008 is one of those years the state controls values, but I don’t need state approval in 2009.” Reynolds said. “It is not standard procedure, but these are not standard times. As a result of the continued housing drop, I will lower values in 2009.

Reynolds is also reviewing the 2008 revaluation process conducted by the appraisal firm hired prior to Reynolds’ recent appointment. The reappraisal was virtually complete by the time Reynolds took office in April.

Permalink | Comments (1) | Post your comment | Categories: County Auditor

‘Stop the hate’

Update: Allow me to be unequivocal: I do not agree whatsoever with Julia Ward’s comment below.

I do not normally respond to comments on this blog, because I aim to facilitate discussion, not control it. But I was troubled by the comment posted by “Jennifer.” If anyone read this article (link below) and thought the newspaper was agreeing with this sentiment, then either it was misread or poorly written. I can assure you everyone at this newspaper, from the publisher down, would like to see a world where race doesn’t matter.

But our job as journalists is to reflect the world as it is, not as we’d like it to be. This is why it was important for this comment to be in this newspaper in the context of an article about racism, sexism and ageism in this year’s presidential election.

So now the question this newspaper sought to explore with this article: Do you belive Sen. Barack Obama’s race, Gov. Sarah Palin’s gender or Sen. John McCain’s age will play a major role on Election Day this year?

Some food for thought:

Original post

That’s what was written on a sign taped to the Hamilton Journal-News front door this morning. Here is the photo (click on it to enlarge):

StopTheHate.jpg

The sign is a response to a story we ran Sunday, Sept. 28, on the role racism, sexism and ageism could play in this year’s presidential race. Here is the story and here is a blog post I wrote with more polling information on the views of Americans on these issues.

The paper has received a lot of comments - and criticism - for this part of the story, namely for quoting Julia Ward of Middletown, who said:

“Black people aren’t smart enough to rule the country. No one should vote for Obama. They just don’t think like the white. I would hate to see (Obama) in office because blacks just aren’t qualified.”

Some say we shouldn’t have allowed such hatred in the newspaper. My view was that some people feel this way, and ignoring it won’t do anyone any good. If we’re going to have a frank discussion on prejudice, we have to first admit that prejudices exist.

Gary Hines, local NAACP president, told me that his one regret about this year’s presidential debate is that it hasn’t spurred an open, honest debate on race in America. I hope we’ve helped bring about that discussion.

Permalink | Comments (3) | Post your comment | Categories: Presidential race

 

Copyright © 2010 Cox Ohio Publishing, Dayton, Ohio, USA. All rights reserved.

By using this site, you accept the terms of our Visitors Agreement and Privacy Policy. You may wish to note our other business policies.